The Battle for Everything is the third studio album by American singer Five for Fighting, released on February 3, 2004 by Aware Records and Columbia Records. Following the success of America Town (2000) and its breakthrough single, "Superman (It's Not Easy)" (2001), John Ondrasik reteamed with producer Gregg Wattenberg and brought in Bill Bottrell to work on new material for his next record. The Battle for Everything debuted at number 20 on the Billboard 200 and spawned four singles: "100 Years", "The Devil in the Wishing Well", "Silent Night", and "If God Made You". The album was certified Platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), denoting sales of over 1,000,000 copies. The album's title refers to the fact "that nothing in the making of this record came easy – including concern over the title itself".

Background and recording

Five for Fighting had achieved a hit record with "Superman (It's Not Easy)" in 2001 leading to his America Town album going Platinum. For the follow-up, Ondrasik went into the studio with record producer Bill Bottrell, best known for his work with Sheryl Crow, in 2003.

On the influences behind Battle and its recording, Ondrasik said, "When I was a kid I could put on Dark Side of the Moon, turn up the sound in my headphones, lie down in the dark, and go away. I wanted that experience again, and so Bill and I were ambitious to the point of absurdity. If we wanted drama, we'd get a thirty-piece orchestra. If we wanted a rock edge, we went after it with reckless abandonment. It was like doing my own private Quadrophenia."

| rev1 = AllMusic

| rev1Score =

| rev2 = Alternative Addiction

| rev2Score =

| rev3 = Billboard

| rev3Score = (favorable)

| rev4 = Blender

| rev4Score =

| rev5 = Common Sense Media

| rev5Score =

| rev6 = Entertainment Weekly

| rev6Score = C+

| rev7 = Melodic

| rev7Score =

| rev8 = People

| rev8Score =

| rev9 = PopMatters

| rev9Score = (Mixed)

| rev10 = Rolling Stone

| rev10Score =

| rev11 = USA Today

| rev11Score =

The Battle for Everything was met with mixed reviews from music critics. At Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an average score of 47, based on 6 reviews.

Billboard's review of the album was positive, saying that the album "impressively tackled new territory". In contrast to other reviews that said the lyrics were overcomplicated, Billboard wrote that Ondrasik had "a knack for writing dead-simple lyrics and turning them into eye-opening reflection". Another favorable review came from People, which selected Battle as a "Critic's Choice" and said it was "a grown-up work rich in melody, lyrical depth and solid musicianship".

J.D. Considine was particularly harsh for Blender. Rating the album one out of five stars, Considine was critical of Ondrasik's attempt at falsetto and considered the album derivative of 1970s soft rock.

Track listing

All songs written by John Ondrasik, except where noted.

Bonus disc

  1. "Silent Night" – 3:42
  2. "Superman (It's Not Easy)" [Acoustic] – 3:43
  3. "Something About You" – 4:01
  4. "Sister Sunshine" – 2:58
  5. "2 + 2 Makes Five" – 2:41

Charts

Weekly charts

{| class="wikitable sortable plainrowheaders" style="text-align:center"

|-

! scope="col"| Chart (2004–2006)

! scope="col"| Peak<br />position

|-

! scope="row"| Australian Albums (ARIA)

| 73

|-

! scope="row"| Canadian Albums (Nielsen SoundScan)

| 33

|-

|-

|}

Year-end charts

{| class="wikitable plainrowheaders" style="text-align:center"

|-

! scope="col"| Chart (2004)

! scope="col"| Position

|-

! scope="row"| US Billboard 200

| 118

|}

References

  • Five for Fighting web page
  • Allmusic The Battle for Everything article