|-
|Chicago Film Critics Association Awards
|Best Supporting Actor
|
|-
|Golden Globes Awards
|Best Supporting Actor - Motion Picture
|
|-
| rowspan="4" |Independent Spirit Awards
|Best Film
|Craig Baumgarten, Tove Christensen, Gaye Hirsch, Adam Merims
|
| rowspan="4" |
|-
|Las Palmas de Gran Canaria International Film Festival Awards
|Best Actor
|Peter Sarsgaard, Hayden Christensen
|
|
|-
|National Society of Film Critics Awards
|Best Supporting Actor
| rowspan="2" |Peter Sarsgaard
|
|
|-
|San Francisco Film Critics Circle Awards
|Best Supporting Actor
|
|
|-
|Best Actor - Motion Picture Drama
|Hayden Christensen
|
|-
|Toronto Film Critics Association Awards
|Best Supporting Actor
|Peter Sarsgaard
|
|
|-
|Best Adapted Screenplay
|Billy Ray
|
|}