Robert William Emmond (November 25, 1869 – August 26, 1935 by 619 votes in the general election. Sims, who lost his deposit, remarked that the PIP was a "little greedy" to win by so much.
Emmond served in opposition for the next two years as a member of the Independent-Farmer legislative group. He contested the 1922 provincial election as a candidate of the United Farmers of Manitoba (UFM),