The Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference (MAAC, /mæk/), to become officially known as the Metro Conference beginning on July 1, 2026, is a collegiate athletic conference affiliated with NCAA Division I. Its current 13 full members are located in five Northeastern states: Connecticut, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, and New York.
Members are all relatively small private institutions, a majority Catholic or formerly Catholic, with the only exceptions being two secular institutions: Rider University and Quinnipiac University.
The MAAC currently sponsors 25 sports and has 17 associate member institutions.
On May 28, 2026, the MAAC announced its intention to rebrand to The Metro Conference, effective July 1, 2026, in an effort to eliminate confusion with the Mid-American Conference's acronym.
In 2011, the conference launched MAAC.TV, the league's first broadband network.
In March 2012, for the first time in 16 years, the MAAC had two teams advance to the NCAA Division I men's basketball tournament, with Loyola earning the league's automatic bid and Iona garnering an at-large bid. Field hockey was added for the 2013–14 academic year. However, field hockey was dropped after the 2018 season. The MAAC field hockey league was effectively taken over by the Northeast Conference (NEC), which reinstated the sport the following year. The conference decided to no longer host a conference championship for men's rowing after the 2016 season, which is governed by the Intercollegiate Rowing Association.
In 2022, Monmouth left the MAAC to join the Colonial Athletic Association, now known as the Coastal Athletic Association. The MAAC responded by entering into negotiations with Mount St. Mary's University, a full but non-football NEC member. ESPN reported on April 27, 2022 that the addition of Mount St. Mary's for 2022–23 and beyond would be finalized in early May. The last of these developments came shortly after the MAAC's greatest success in men's basketball, when Saint Peter's became the first 15-seed ever to reach an NCAA regional final, losing there to eventual national runner-up No. 8 North Carolina. Mount St. Mary's would be confirmed as Monmouth's replacement on May 2.
Also in 2022, four schools that were already MAAC affiliates added men's lacrosse to their MAAC memberships. All were full members of conferences that dropped the sport following the addition of men's lacrosse by the Atlantic 10 Conference. LIU, Sacred Heart, and Wagner are members of the Northeast Conference (now officially NEC), and VMI is a member of the Southern Conference. LIU is the only one of the four that had not previously housed men's lacrosse in the MAAC.
Merrimack College and Sacred Heart University joined the conference for the 2024-25 season.
Athletic and academic success
Over the conference's history, MAAC teams have achieved national acclaim in many sports. In the summer of 2002, the Marist men's varsity eight boat advanced to the semifinals of the Temple Challenge Cup at the Henley Royal Regatta. In 2007, the Marist women's basketball team advanced to the Sweet 16 of the NCAA Division I women's basketball tournament. The Red Foxes have recorded five NCAA wins since their run in 2007. In the fall of 2011, the Iona men's cross country team finished tied for ninth place at the NCAA Championship race, extending the Gaels' streak to 10 straight Top 10 national finishes. With an overall record of 22–12, Saint Peter's had the best NCAA postseason run with the most wins in a single NCAA Tournament by any MAAC program (men or women) in the conference's 41-year history. In basketball, MAAC teams have made a total of 80 NIT appearances and 50 NCAA basketball tournament appearances.
| Red Foxes
| 1997
|
|-
| Merrimack College
| North Andover, Massachusetts
| 1947
| Catholic<br />
| 5,700
| $97.4
| Warriors
| 2024
|
|-
| Mount St. Mary's University
| Emmitsburg, Maryland
| 1808
| Catholic<br />
| 1,889
| $47.605
| Mountaineers
| 2022
|
|-
| Niagara University
| Lewiston, New York
| 1856
| Catholic<br />(Vincentian)
| 3,765
| $102.4
| Purple Eagles
| 1989
|
|-
| Quinnipiac University
| Hamden, Connecticut
| 1929
| Nonsectarian
| 10,207
| $753.872
| Bobcats
| 2013
|
|-
| Rider University
| Lawrenceville, New Jersey
| 1865
| Nonsectarian
| 4,825
| $64.3
| Broncs
| 1997
|
|-
| Sacred Heart University
| Fairfield, Connecticut
| 1963
| Catholic<br />
| 5,974
| $246.0
| Pioneers
| 2024
|
|-
| Saint Peter's University
| Jersey City, New Jersey
| 1872
| Catholic<br />
| 3,452
| $43.6
| Peacocks
| 1981
|
|-
| Siena University
| Loudonville, New York
| 1937
| Catholic<br />(Franciscan)
| 3,224
| $135.3
| Saints
| 1989
|
|}
;Notes:
Associate members
Of the MAAC's ten current affiliate members, only two are Catholic. Drake, Jacksonville, LIU, Robert Morris, and Stetson are nonsectarian and Wagner College is Lutheran. There are also two public institutions, the University at Albany and the Virginia Military Institute.
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
! Institution
! Location
! Founded
! Type
! Enrollment
! Nickname
! Joined
! MAAC<br />sport(s)
! Primary<br />conference
|-
|
| Albany, New York
| 1844
| Public
| 17,944
| Great Danes
| 2009
|
| America East (AmEast)
|-
| Drake University
| Des Moines, Iowa
| 1881
| Nonsectarian
| 4,869
| Bulldogs
| 2009
|
| Missouri Valley (MVC)
|-
| Jacksonville University
| Jacksonville, Florida
| 1934
| Nonsectarian
| 4,213
| Dolphins
| 2011
|
| Atlantic Sun (ASUN)
|-
| La Salle University
| Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
| 1863
| Catholic<br />
| 5,191
| Explorers
| 2016
|
| Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
| rowspan=2 | Long Island University
| rowspan=2 | Brooklyn & Brookville, New York
| rowspan=2 | 1926
| rowspan=2 | Nonsectarian
| rowspan=2 | 15,197
| rowspan=2 | Sharks
| 2019
|
| rowspan=2 | Northeast (NEC)
|-
| 2022
|
|-
| Robert Morris University
| Moon Township, Pennsylvania
| 1921
| Nonsectarian
| 4,895
| Colonials
| 2010
|
| Horizon
|-
| Stetson University
| DeLand, Florida
| 1883
| Nonsectarian
| 4,341
| Hatters
| 2013
|
| Atlantic Sun (ASUN)
|-
| Villanova University
| Villanova, Pennsylvania
| 1842
| Catholic<br />
| 11,023
| Wildcats
| 2003
|
| Big East
|-
| Virginia Military Institute<br />
| Lexington, Virginia
| 1839
| S.M.C.
| 1,685
| Keydets
| 2011
|
| Southern (SoCon)
|-
| Wagner College
| Staten Island, New York
| 1883
| Lutheran ELCA
| 2,211
| Seahawks
| 2003
|
| Northeast (NEC)
|}
;Notes:
<!--
Future
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
!Institution
!Location
!Founded
!Joining
!Type
!Enrollment
!Nickname
!Primary<br />conference
!MAAC<br />sport
|-
|}
-->
Former members
Former full members
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
! Institution
! Location
! Founded
! Type
! Nickname
! Joined
! Left
! class="unsortable" | Colors
! Current<br />conference
|-
| <br />
| West Point, New York
| 1802
| Federal<br />
| Black Knights
| 1981
| 1990
|
| Patriot
|-
| Fordham University
| Bronx, New York
| 1841
| Catholic<br />
| Rams
| 1981
| 1990
|
| Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
|
| Worcester, Massachusetts
| 1843
| Catholic<br />
| Crusaders
| 1983
| 1990
|
| Patriot
|-
| La Salle University
| Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
| 1863
| Catholic<br />
| Explorers
| 1983
| 1992
|
| Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
| Loyola University Maryland
| Baltimore, Maryland
| 1852
| Catholic<br />
| Greyhounds
| 1989
| 2013
|
| Patriot
|-
| Monmouth University
| West Long Branch, New Jersey
| 1933
| Nonsectarian
| Hawks
| 2013
| 2022
|
| Coastal (CAA)
|}
;Notes:
Former associate members
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
! Institution
! Location
! Founded
! Type
! Nickname
! Joined
! Left
! MAAC<br />sport(s)
! Current<br />primary<br />conference
! Current<br />conference,<br />former<br />MAAC sport(s)
|-
| Boston University
| Boston,<br />Massachusetts
| 1839
| Nonsectarian
| Terriers
| 2009
| 2013
|
| colspan="2" | Patriot
|-
| rowspan="2" | Bryant University
| rowspan="2" | Smithfield,<br />Rhode Island
| rowspan="2" | 1863
| rowspan="2" | Nonsectarian
| rowspan="2" | Bulldogs
| 2012
| 2020
|
| colspan="2" rowspan="2" | America East (AmEast)
|-
| 2013
| 2019
| Field hockey
|-
| Butler University
| Indianapolis,<br />Indiana
| 1855
| Nonsectarian
| Bulldogs
| 2012
| 2013
|
| colspan="2" | Big East
|-
| Colgate University
| Hamilton,<br />New York
| 1819
| Nonsectarian
| Raiders
| 1989
| 1990
| Baseball
| Patriot
| N/A
|-
|
| Dayton,<br />Ohio
| 1850
| Catholic<br />
| Flyers
| 2014
| 2024
|
| colspan="2" | Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
|
| Detroit,<br />Michigan
| 1877
| Catholic<br />
| Titans
| 2009
| 2021
|
| Horizon
| Northeast (NEC)
|-
| rowspan="2" | Duquesne University
| rowspan="2" | Pittsburgh,<br />Pennsylvania
| rowspan="2" | 1878
| rowspan="2" | Catholic<br />
| rowspan="2" | Dukes
| 1994
| 2008
| Football
| rowspan="2" | Atlantic 10 (A10)
| Northeast (NEC)
|-
| 1996
| 1998
|
| Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
| Georgetown University
| Washington, D.C.
| 1789
| Catholic<br />
| Hoyas
| 1993
| 2000
| Football
| Big East
| Patriot
|-
|
| West Hartford,<br />Connecticut
| 1877
| Nonsectarian
| Hawks
| 2009
| 2022
|
| colspan="2" | C. New England (CNE)
|-
| Jacksonville University
| Jacksonville,<br />Florida
| 1934
| Nonsectarian
| Dolphins
| 2010
| 2013
|
| colspan="2" | Atlantic Sun (ASUN)
|-
| rowspan="2" | La Salle University
| rowspan="2" | Philadelphia,<br />Pennsylvania
| rowspan="2" | 1863
| rowspan="2" | Catholic<br />
| rowspan="2" | Explorers
| 1999
| 2008
| Football
| rowspan="2" | Atlantic 10 (A10)
|
|-
| 2016
| 2024
|
| Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
| rowspan="2" | Le Moyne College
| rowspan="2" | Syracuse<br />New York
| rowspan="2" | 1946
| rowspan="2" | Catholic<br />
| rowspan="2" | Dolphins
| 1989
| 2008
| Baseball
| colspan="2" rowspan="2" | Northeast (NEC)
|-
| 1998
| 2007
|
|-
| Long Island University
| Brooklyn &<br />Brookville<br />New York<br />
| Brooklyn,<br />New York
| 1926
| Nonsectarian
| Blackbirds
| 2016
| 2019
| Field hockey
| colspan="2" | Northeast (NEC)
|-
| Loyola University Chicago
| Chicago,<br />Illinois
| 1870
| Catholic<br />
| Ramblers
| 2022
| 2024
|
| colspan="2" | Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
| rowspan="6" | Marist College
| rowspan="6" | Poughkeepsie<br />New York
| rowspan="6" | 1929
| rowspan="6" | Nonsectarian
| rowspan="6" | Red Foxes
| 1995
| 1997
|
| colspan="2" rowspan="6" | Metro Atlantic (MAAC)
|-
| 1996
| 1997
|
|-
| 1995
| 1997
|
|-
| 1996
| 1997
|
|-
| 1996
| 1997
|
|-
| 1995
| 1997
|
|-
| rowspan="2" | Mount St. Mary's University
| rowspan="2" | Emmitsburg,<br />Maryland
| rowspan="2" | 1808
| rowspan="2" | Catholic<br />
| rowspan="2" | Mountaineers
| 1995
| 2010
|
| colspan="2" rowspan="2" | Metro Atlantic (MAAC)
|-
| 1996
| 1998
|
|-
| Providence College
| Providence<br />Rhode Island
| 1917
| Catholic<br />
| Friars
| 1995
| 2009
|
| colspan="2" | Big East
|-
| Quinnipiac University
| Hamden,<br />Connecticut
| 1929
| Nonsectarian
| Bobcats
| 1998
| 2001
|
| colspan="2" | Metro Atlantic (MAAC)
|-
| rowspan="2" | Rider University
| rowspan="2" | Lawrenceville,<br />New Jersey
| rowspan="2" | 1865
| rowspan="2" | Nonsectarian
| rowspan="2" | Broncs
| 1995
| 1997
|
| colspan="2" rowspan="2" | Metro Atlantic (MAAC)
|-
| 1995
| 1997
|
|-
| Robert Morris University
| Moon Township,<br />Pennsylvania
| 1921
| Nonsectarian
| Colonials
| 2013
| 2014
| Field hockey
| Horizon
|
|-
| rowspan="4" | Sacred Heart University
| rowspan="4" | Fairfield,<br />Connecticut
| rowspan="4" | 1963
| rowspan="4" | Catholic<br />
| rowspan="4" | Pioneers
| 1999
| 2001
| rowspan="2" |
| colspan="2" rowspan="4" | Metro Atlantic (MAAC)
|-
| 2022
| 2024
|-
| 2007
| 2024
|
|-
| 2013
| 2019
| Field hockey
|-
|
|
| 1858
| Catholic<br />
| Bonnies
| 2018
| 2022
|
| colspan="2" | Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
|
| Brooklyn Heights,<br />New York
| 1859
| Catholic<br />
| Terriers
| 2003
| 2023
|
| colspan="2" |
|-
| Saint Joseph's University
| Philadelphia,<br />Pennsylvania
| 1851
| Catholic<br />
| Hawks
| 1996
| 2010
|
| colspan="2" | Atlantic 10 (A10)
|-
| rowspan="2" |
| rowspan="2" | Queens,<br />New York
| rowspan="2" | 1870
| rowspan="2" | Catholic<br />
| rowspan="2" | Red Storm
| 1993
| 1999
| rowspan="2" | Football
| rowspan="2" | Big East
| rowspan="2" |
|-
| 2002
| 2003
|-
| rowspan="2" | Virginia Military Institute<br />
| rowspan="2" | Lexington,<br />Virginia
| rowspan="2" | 1839
| rowspan="2" | S.M.C.
| rowspan="2" | Keydets
| 2002
| 2013
| rowspan="2" |
| rowspan="2" | Southern (SoCon)
| rowspan="2" | Northeast (NEC)
|-
| 2022
| 2024
|-
| rowspan="3" | Wagner College
| rowspan="3" | Staten Island,<br />New York
| rowspan="3" | 1883
| rowspan="3" | Lutheran ELCA
| rowspan="3" | Seahawks
| 1999
| 2010
| rowspan="2" |
| colspan="2" rowspan="3" | Northeast (NEC)
|-
| 2022
| 2024
|-
| 1996
| 1998
|
|}
;Notes:
Membership timeline
<timeline>
DateFormat = yyyy
ImageSize = width:1000 height:auto barincrement:20
Period = from:1981 till:2031
TimeAxis = orientation:horizontal
PlotArea = right:5 left:5 bottom:40 top:5
Colors =
id:line value:black
id:bg value:white
id:Full value:rgb(0.7,0.9,0.8) # Use this color to denote a team that is a member in all sports
id:FullxF value:rgb(0.9,0.8,0.7) # Use this color to denote a team that is a member in all sports except for football
id:AssocF value:rgb(0.9,0.7,0.8) # Use this color to denote a team that is a member for football only
id:AssocOS value:rgb(0.8,0.9,0.7) # Use this color to denote a team that is a member for another sport only
id:OtherC1 value:rgb(0.996,0.996,0.699) # Use this color to denote a team that has moved in another conference
id:OtherC2 value:rgb(0.988,0.703,0.383) # Use this color to denote a team that has moved in another conference when the other color has already been used
PlotData=
width:15 textcolor:black shift:(5,-5) anchor:from fontsize:s
bar:1 color:FullxF from:1981 till:1990 text:Army (1981–1990)
bar:1 color:OtherC1 from:1990 till:end text:Patriot
bar:2 color:FullxF from:1981 till:1990 text:Fordham (1981–1990)
bar:2 color:OtherC1 from:1990 till:1995 text:Patriot
bar:2 color:OtherC2 from:1995 till:end text:A-10
bar:3 color:FullxF from:1981 till:1996 text:Fairfield (1981–present)
bar:3 color:Full from:1996 till:2003
bar:3 color:FullxF from:2003 till:end
bar:4 color:FullxF from:1981 till:1993 text:Iona (1981–present)
bar:4 color:Full from:1993 till:2008
bar:4 color:FullxF from:2008 till:end
bar:5 color:FullxF from:1981 till:end text:Manhattan (1981–present)
bar:6 color:FullxF from:1981 till:1993 text:Saint Peter's (1981–present)
bar:6 color:Full from:1993 till:2007
bar:6 color:FullxF from:2007 till:end
bar:7 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1983 text:ECAC-N
bar:7 shift:(20) color:FullxF from:1983 till:1990 text:Holy Cross (1983–1990)
bar:7 color:OtherC1 from:1990 till:end text:Patriot
bar:8 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1983 text:ECC
bar:8 color:FullxF from:1983 till:1992 text:La Salle (1983–1992)
bar:8 color:OtherC1 from:1992 till:1995 text:Mid-Col
bar:8 color:OtherC2 from:1995 till:1999 text:A-10
bar:8 color:AssocF from:1999 till:2008 text:A-10 (MAAC fb.)
bar:8 color:OtherC1 from:2008 till:end text:A-10
bar:9 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1989 text:NEC
bar:9 color:FullxF from:1989 till:2013 text:Loyola (Md.) (1989–2013)
bar:9 color:OtherC1 from:2013 till:end text:Patriot
bar:10 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1989 text:ECAC North
bar:10 color:FullxF from:1989 till:1993 text:Canisius (1989–present)
bar:10 color:Full from:1993 till:2003
bar:10 color:FullxF from:2003 till:end
bar:11 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1989 text:ECAC North
bar:11 color:FullxF from:1989 till:end text:Niagara (1989–present)
bar:12 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1984 text:NEC
bar:12 color:OtherC2 from:1984 till:1989 text:ECAC North
bar:12 color:FullxF from:1989 till:1993 text:Siena (1989–present)
bar:12 color:Full from:1993 till:2004
bar:12 color:FullxF from:2004 till:end
bar:13 color:AssocF from:1993 till:1999 text:St. John's (N.Y.) (1993–1998)
bar:13 color:AssocF from:2002 till:2003 text:(2002 only)
bar:14 color:AssocF from:1993 till:2001 text:Georgetown (1993–2000)
bar:15 color:AssocF from:1994 till:2008 text:Duquesne (1994–2008)
bar:16 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1994 text:NEC
bar:16 shift:(-20) color:AssocF from:1994 till:1997 text:(fb. 1994–1997)
bar:16 color:Full from:1997 till:2008 text:Marist (1997–present)
bar:16 color:FullxF from:2008 till:end
bar:17 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1992 text:ECC
bar:17 color:OtherC2 from:1992 till:1997 text:NEC
bar:17 color:FullxF from:1997 till:end text:Rider (1997–present)
bar:18 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1985 text:Ind.
bar:18 color:OtherC2 from:1985 till:2013 text:NEC
bar:18 color:FullxF from:2013 till:2022 text:Monmouth (2013–2022)
bar:18 color:OtherC1 from:2022 till:end text:CAA
bar:19 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1987 text:NECC
bar:19 color:OtherC2 from:1987 till:1998 text:NE-10
bar:19 color:OtherC1 from:1998 till:2013 text:NEC
bar:19 color:FullxF from:2013 till:end text:Quinnipiac (2013–present)
bar:20 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1989 text:Ind.
bar:20 color:OtherC2 from:1989 till:2022 text:NEC
bar:20 color:FullxF from:2022 till:end text:Mount St. Mary's (2022–present)
bar:21 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1999 text:NECC
bar:21 color:AssocOS from:1999 till:2001 text: (m.lax. 1999–2001)
bar:21 shift:(70) color:OtherC1 from:2001 till:2007 text:NEC
bar:21 color:AssocOS from:2007 till:2024 text: (w.row. 2007–2024; f.h. 2013–2019; m.lax. 2023–2024)
bar:21 color:FullxF from:2024 till:end text:Sacred Heart (2024–present)
bar:22 color:OtherC1 from:1981 till:1984 text:Ind.
bar:22 color:OtherC2 from:1984 till:2019 text:NE-10
bar:22 color:OtherC1 from:2019 till:2024 text:NEC
bar:22 color:FullxF from:2024 till:end text:Merrimack (2024–present)
ScaleMajor = gridcolor:line unit:year increment:2 start:1981
TextData =
fontsize:M
textcolor:black
pos:(0,20) tabs:(400-center)
text:^"Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference membership history"
- > If the chart uses more than one bar color, add a legend by selecting the appropriate fields from the following three options (use only the colors that are used in the graphic.) Leave a blank line after the end of the timeline, then add a line with the selected values from the list, separated by a space.
<#
</timeline>
Sports
The Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference sponsors championship competition in 10 men's and 13 women's NCAA sanctioned sports, plus two sports not organized by the NCAA - esports, which are fully coeducational, and men's rowing.
{| class="wikitable" style=
|+ Teams in Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference competition
! Sport || Men's || Women's || Coed
|-
| Baseball || || ||
|-
| Basketball || || ||
|-
| Cross country || || ||
|-
| Esports || || ||
|-
| Golf || || ||
|-
| Lacrosse || || ||
|-
| Rowing || || ||
|-
| Soccer || || ||
|-
| Softball || || ||
|-
| Swimming and diving || || ||
|-
| Tennis || || ||
|-
| Track and field (indoor) || || ||
|-
| Track and field (outdoor) || || ||
|-
| Volleyball || || ||
|-
| Water polo || || ||
|}
Men's
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center; width:80%;"
|-
! <big>School</big>!! Baseball !! Basketball !! Cross country !! Esports !! Golf !! Lacrosse !! Rowing !! Soccer !! Swimming !! Tennis !! Track and field<br />(indoor) !! Track and field<br />(outdoor) !! Total MAAC sports
|-
| <big>Canisius</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 10
|-
| <big>Fairfield</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 8
|-
| <big>Iona</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 10
|-
| <big>Manhattan</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 11
|-
| <big>Marist</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 11
|-
| <big>Merrimack</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 9
|-
| <big>Mount St. Mary's</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 11
|-
| <big>Niagara</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 8
|-
| <big>Quinnipiac</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 7
|-
| <big>Rider</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 9
|-
| <big>Sacred Heart</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 9
|-
| <big>Saint Peter's</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 9
|-
| <big>Siena</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || 9
|-
|<big>Totals</big> || 13 || 13 || 13 || 8 || 11 || 9 || 4+1 || 13 || 9 || 9 || 9 || 10 || 120+1
|}
Unsponsored
<!--Future members are highlighted in gray.-->
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center;"
|-
! <big>School</big> !! Fencing !! Football !! Ice hockey !! Volleyball !! Water polo !! Wrestling
|-
| <big>Canisius</big> || No || No || AHA || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Iona</big> || No || No || No || No || CWPA || No
|-
| <big>Manhattan</big> || No || No || No || NEC || No || No
|-
| <big>Marist</big> || No || PFL || No || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Merrimack</big> || No || Independent || Hockey East || Independent || No || No
|-
| <big>Mount St. Mary's</big> || No || No || No || No || CWPA || No
|-
| <big>Niagara</big> || No || No || AHA || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Quinnipiac</big> || No || No || ECAC || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Rider</big> || No || No || No || No || No || MAC
|-
| <big>Sacred Heart</big> || <abbr title="New England Intercollegiate Fencing Conference">NEIFC</abbr> || Independent || AHA || EIVA || No || EIWA
|}
;Notes
Women's
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center; width:90%;"
|-
! School!! Basketball !! Cross<br />country !! Esports !! Golf !! Lacrosse !! Rowing !! Soccer !! Softball !! Swimming !! Tennis !! Track and field<br />(indoor) !! Track and field<br />(outdoor) !! Volleyball !! Water<br />polo !! Total<br />MAAC sports
|-
| <big>Canisius</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || 11
|-
| <big>Fairfield</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || 10
|-
| <big>Iona</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || 9
|-
| <big>Siena</big> || || || || || || || || || || || || || || || 12
|-
| <big>Totals</big> || 13 || 13 || 8 || 7+1 || 12 || 8+5 || 13 || 13 || 12 || 10 || 11 || 11 || 12 || 4+5 || 131+11
|}
Unsponsored
<!--Future members are highlighted in gray.-->
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center;"
|-
! <big>School</big> !! Acrobatics and<br />tumbling !! Bowling !! Equestrian !! Fencing !! Flag football !! Field hockey !! Ice hockey !! Rugby || Wrestling
|-
| <big>Canisius</big> || Independent || No || No || No || No || No || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Fairfield</big> || No || No || No || No || No || NEC || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Manhattan</big> || Independent || No || No || No || No || No || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Merrimack</big> || No || Independent || No || No || No || NEC || Hockey East || No || No
|-
| <big>Mount St. Mary's</big> || No || Independent || No || No || CC || No || No || Independent || No
|-
| <big>Niagara</big> || No || NEC || No || No || No || No || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Quinnipiac</big> || Independent || No || No || No || No || Big East || ECAC || Independent || No
|-
| <big>Rider</big> || No || No || No || No || No || NEC || No || No || No
|-
| <big>Sacred Heart</big> || No || CUSA || Independent || <abbr title="New England Intercollegiate Fencing Conference">NEIFC</abbr> || No || NEC || NEWHA || Independent || Independent
|}
;Notes
Facilities
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="margin: auto;"
|-
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|
|Koessler Athletic Center
|2,176
|Demske Sports Complex
|1,200
|Demske Sports Complex
|1,200
|-
| style="text-align:center; "| Fairfield Stags|
|Leo D. Mahoney Arena
|3,500
|Alumni Baseball Diamond
|600
|Lessing Field
|600
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|
|Hynes Athletic Center
|2,611
|City Park
|
|Mazzella Field
|2,440
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|Manhattan Jaspers|
|Draddy Gymnasium
|2,345
|Clover Stadium
|9,362
|Gaelic Park
|2,000
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|Marist Red Foxes|
|McCann Arena
|3,200
|James J. McCann Baseball Field
|350
|Tenney Stadium
|5,000
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|
| Hammel Court
| 1,200
| Warrior Baseball Diamond
|
| Martone–Mejail Field
| 3,000
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|Mount St. Mary's Mountaineers|
|Knott Arena
|3,121
|E. T. Straw Family Stadium
|
|Waldron Family Stadium
|1,000
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|
|Gallagher Center
|2,400
|Bobo Field
|
|Niagara Field
|1,200
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|
|People's United Center
|3,570
|Quinnipiac Baseball Field
|
|Quinnipiac Soccer Field
|
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|Rider Broncs|
|Alumni Gymnasium
|1,650
|Sonny Pittaro Field
|2,000
|Ben Cohen Field
|1,000
|-
| style="text-align:center; "| Sacred Heart Pioneers|
| William H. Pitt Center
| 2,100
| Veterans Memorial Park
| 500
| Park Avenue Field
|
|-
| style="text-align:center; "| Saint Peter's Peacocks|
|Run Baby Run Arena
|3,200
|Joseph J. Jaroschak Field
|
|Joseph J. Jaroschak Field
|
|-
| style="text-align:center; "|Siena Saints|
|MVP Arena (men) <br /> Alumni Recreation Center (women)
|15,229<br />4,000
|Siena Baseball Field
|500
|Siena Turf Field
|1,000
|}
<gallery class="center" perrow="4">
File:Fairfield Alumni Baseball Diamond.JPG|Alumni Baseball Diamond<br />Fairfield Stags
File:Marist vs Fairfield, Leo D. Mahoney Arena.jpg|Leo D. Mahoney Arena<br />Fairfield Stags
File:Fairfield Lessing Field.JPG|Lessing Field<br />Fairfield Stags
File:Hynes Athletics Center and Mazzella Field.jpg|Hynes Athletic Center<br />Iona Gaels
File:McCann Arena.JPG|McCann Arena<br />Marist Red Foxes
File:Tenney Stadium at Leonidoff Field.jpg|Tenney Stadium<br />Marist Red Foxes
File:Niagara University Gallagher Center.jpg|Gallagher Center<br />Niagara Purple Eagles
File:TDBankNorthCenter.jpg|TD Bank Sports Center<br />Quinnipiac Bobcats
Image:YanitelliCenterOutside.jpg|Run Baby Run Arena<br />Saint Peter's Peacocks
File:Times Union Center 2011.jpg|MVP Arena<br />Siena Saints
</gallery>
Basketball
Men's
{| class="wikitable sortable"
!Year
!Regular season champion(s)
!Tournament champion
!Player of the Year
!Defensive Player of the Year
!Coach of the Year
|-
| 1982
| Saint Peter's (20–9, 9–1)
| (3) Iona (24–9, 7–3)
|William Brown (Saint Peter's)
|
|Bob Dukiet (Saint Peter's)
|-
| 1983
| Iona (22–9, 8–2)
| (2) Fordham (19–11, 7–3)
|Steve Burtt, Sr. (Iona)
|
|Gordon Chiesa (Manhattan)
|-
| 1984
| La Salle (20–11, 11–3) <br /> Saint Peter's (23–6, 11–3) <br /> Iona
| (3) Iona (23–8, 11–3)
|Steve Burtt, Sr. (Iona)
|
|Pat Kennedy (Iona)
|-
|1985
| Iona
| (1) Iona (26–5, 11–3)
|Randy Cozzens (Army)
|
|Les Wothke (Army)
|-
|1986
| Fairfield
| (1) Fairfield (24–7, 13–1)
|Tony George (Fairfield)
|
|Mitch Buonaguro (Fairfield)
|-
|1987
| Saint Peter's (21–8, 11–3)
| (7) Fairfield (15–16, 5–9)
|Kevin Houston (Army)
|
|Ted Fiore (Saint Peter's)
|-
|1988
| La Salle
| (1) La Salle (24–10, 14–0)
|Lionel Simmons (La Salle)
|
|Speedy Morris (La Salle)
|-
|1989
| La Salle
| (1) La Salle (26–6, 13–1)
|Lionel Simmons (La Salle)
|
|Speedy Morris (La Salle)<br />Ted Fiore (Saint Peter's)
|-
|1990
| (N) Holy Cross (24–6, 14–2) <br /> (S) La Salle
| (S1) La Salle (30–2, 16–0)
|Lionel Simmons (La Salle)
|
|George Blaney (Holy Cross)
|-
|1991
| Siena (25–10, 12–4) <br /> La Salle (19–10, 12–4)
| (3) Saint Peter's (24–7, 11–5)
|Marc Brown (Siena)
|
|Ted Fiore (Saint Peter's)
|-
|1992
| Manhattan (25–9, 13–3)
| (2) La Salle (20–11, 12–4)
|Randy Woods (La Salle)
|
|Steve Lappas (Manhattan)
|-
|1993
| Manhattan
| (1) Manhattan (23–7, 12–2)
|Keith Bullock (Manhattan)
|
|Jack Armstrong (Niagara)
|-
|1994
| Canisius (22–7, 12–2)
| (5) Loyola (MD) (17–13, 6–8)
|Doremus Bennerman (Siena)
|
|John Beilein (Canisius)
|-
|1995
| Manhattan (26–5, 12–2)
| (3) Saint Peter's (19–11, 10–4)
|Craig Wise (Canisius)
|
|Fran Fraschilla (Manhattan)
|-
|1996
| Iona (21–8, 10–4) <br />Fairfield (20–10, 10–4)
| (5) Canisius (19–11, 7–7)
|Darrell Barley (Canisius)
|
|Paul Cormier (Fairfield)
|-
|1997
| Iona (22–8, 11–3)
| (8) Fairfield (11–19, 2–12)
|Mindaugas Timinskas (Iona)
|
|Tim Welsh (Iona)
|-
|1998
| Iona
| (1) Iona (27–6, 15–3)
|Kashif Hameed (Iona)
|
|Tim Welsh (Iona)
|-
|1999
| Niagara (17–12, 13–5) <br /> Siena
| (2) Siena (25–6, 13–5)
|Alvin Young (Niagara)
|
|Joe Mihalich (Niagara)
|-
|2000
| Siena (24–9, 15–3)
| (2) Iona (20–11, 13–5)
|Tariq Kirksay (Iona)
|
|Paul Hewitt (Siena)
|-
|2001
| Iona<br />Niagara (15–13, 12–6)<br />Siena (20–11, 12–6)
| (1) Iona (22–11, 12–6)
|Demond Stewart (Niagara)
|
|Dave Magarity (Marist)
|-
|2002
| Rider (17–11, 13–5) <br /> Marist (19–9, 13–5)
| (7) Siena (17–19, 9–9)
|Mario Porter (Rider)
|Deng Gai (Fairfield)
|Don Harnum (Rider)
|-
|2003
| Manhattan
| (1) Manhattan (23–7, 14–4)
|Luis Flores (Manhattan)
|Deng Gai (Fairfield)
|Bobby Gonzalez (Manhattan)
|-
|2004
| Manhattan
| (1) Manhattan (25–6, 16–2)
|Luis Flores (Manhattan)
|Tyquawn Goode (Fairfield)
|Tim O'Toole (Fairfield)
|-
|2005
| Niagara <br /> Rider (19–11, 13–5)
| (1) Niagara (20–10, 13–5)
|Juan Mendez (Niagara)
|Deng Gai (Fairfield)
|Joe Mihalich (Niagara)
|-
|2006
| Manhattan (20–11, 14–4)
| (2) Iona (23–8, 13–5)
|Keydren Clark (Saint Peter's)
|Ricky Soliver (Iona)
|Bobby Gonzalez (Manhattan)
|-
|2007
| Marist (25–9, 14–4)
| (2) Niagara (23–12, 13–5)
|Jared Jordan (Marist)
|Jason Thompson (Rider)
|Matt Brady (Marist)
|-
|2008
|Siena <br /> Rider (13–5)
|(1) Siena (23–11, 13–5)
|Jason Thompson (Rider)
|Jason Thompson (Rider)
|Tommy Dempsey (Rider)
|-
|2009
|Siena
|(1) Siena (27–8, 16–2)
|Kenny Hasbrouck (Siena)
|Tyrone Lewis (Niagara)
|Fran McCaffery (Siena)
|-
|2010
|Siena
|(1) Siena (27–7, 17–1)
|Alex Franklin (Siena)
|Anthony Johnson (Fairfield)
|Kevin Willard (Iona)
|-
|2011
|Fairfield (25–8, 15–3)
|(4) Saint Peter's (20–14, 11–7)
| (Siena)
| (Niagara)
| (Fairfield)
|-
|2012
|Iona (25–8, 15–3)
|(2) Loyola (MD) (24–9, 13–5)
| (Iona)
| (Manhattan)
| (Loyola (MD))
|-
|2013
|Niagara (19–14, 13–5)
|(4) Iona (20–14, 11–7)
| (Iona)
| (Manhattan)
| (Niagara)
|-
|2014
|Iona (22–11, 17–3)
|(2) Manhattan (25–8, 15–5)
| (Canisius)
| (Manhattan)
| (Iona)
|-
|2015
|Iona (26–9, 17–3)
|(3) Manhattan (19–14, 13–7)
| (Iona)
| (Quinnipiac)
| (Rider)
|-
|2016
|Monmouth (28–8, 17–3)
|(2) Iona (22–11, 16–4)
| (Monmouth)
| (Siena)
| (Monmouth)
|-
|2017
|Monmouth (27–7, 18–2)
|(3) Iona (22–13, 12–8)
| (Monmouth)
| (Saint Peter's)
| (Monmouth)
|-
|2018
|Rider (22–10, 15–3) <br /> Canisius (21–12, 15–3)
|(4) Iona (20–14, 11–7)
| (Canisius) <br /> (Niagara)
| (Manhattan)
| (Rider)
|-
|2019
|Iona
|(1) Iona (17–15, 12–6)
| (Quinnipiac)
| (Fairfield)
| (Iona)
|-
|2020
|Siena (19–10, 15–5)
!scope="row" style="text-align:center"|
| (Siena)
| (Saint Peter's)
| (Saint Peter's)
|-
|2021
|Siena (12–4, 12–4) <br /> Monmouth (12–6, 12–7)
||(9) Iona (12–5, 6–3)
| (Siena)
| (Saint Peter's)
| (Monmouth)
|-
|2022
|Iona (25–6, 17–3)
|(2) Saint Peter's (19–11, 14–6)
| (Iona)
| (Saint Peter's)
| (Iona)
|-
|2023
|Iona (25–7, 17-3)
|(1) Iona
| (Iona)
| (Iona) <br /> (Manhattan)
| (Iona)
|-
|2024
|Quinnipiac (23–8, 15-5)
|(5) Saint Peter's (19-14, 12-8)
| (Quinnipiac)
| (Saint Peter's)
| (Quinnipiac)
|-
|2025
|Quinnipiac (20-13, 15-5)
|(6) Mount St. Mary's (22-12, 12-8)
| (Quinnipiac)
| (Merrimack)
| (Quinnipiac)
|-
|2026
|Merrimack (21-10, 17-3)
|(3) Siena (22-10, 13-7)
| (Merrimack)
| (Merrimack)
| (Merrimack)
|}
;Notes
- MAAC men's basketball conference tournament locations
Postseason history
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
{| class= "wikitable sortable"
|+NCAA tournament<br/>(11–44)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|-
| 1984
| (10) Iona
| (7) Virginia
| L 57–58
|-
| 1985
| (13) Iona
| (4) Loyola (IL)
| L 58–59
|-
| 1986
| (13) Fairfield
| (4) Illinois
| L 51–75
|-
| 1987
| (16) Fairfield
| (1) Indiana
| L 58–92
|-
| 1988
| (13) La Salle
| (4) Kansas St.
| L 53–66
|-
| 1989
| (8) La Salle
| (9) Louisiana Tech
| L 74–83
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1990
| (4) La Salle
| (13) So. Mississippi<br />(5) Clemson
| W 79–63<br />L 75–79
|-
| 1991
| (12) Saint Peter's
| (5) Texas
| L 65–73
|-
| 1992
| (13) La Salle
| (4) Seton Hall
| L 76–78
|-
| 1993
| (11) Manhattan
| (6) Virginia
| L 66–78
|-
| 1994
| (15) Loyola (MD)
| (2) Arizona
| L 55–81
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1995
| (15) Saint Peter's<br />(13) Manhattan
| (2) Massachusetts<br />(4) Oklahoma<br />(5) Arizona St.
| L 51–68<br />W 77–67<br />L 54–64
|-
| 1996
| (13) Canisius
| (4) Utah
| L 43–72
|-
| 1997
| (16) Fairfield
| (1) North Carolina
| L 74–82
|-
| 1998
| (12) Iona
| (5) Syracuse
| L 61–63
|-
| 1999
| (13) Siena
| (4) Arkansas
| L 80–94
|-
| 2000
| (14) Iona
| (3) Maryland
| L 59–74
|-
| 2001
| (14) Iona
| (3) Mississippi
| L 70–72
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2002
| (16) Siena
| (16) Alcorn St.<br />(1) Maryland
| W 81–77<br />L 70–85
|-
| 2003
| (14) Manhattan
| (3) Syracuse
| L 65–76
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2004
| (12) Manhattan
| (5) Florida<br />(4) Wake Forest
| W 75–60<br />L 80–84
|-
| 2005
| (14) Niagara
| (3) Oklahoma
| L 67–84
|-
| 2006
| (13) Iona
| (4) LSU
| L 64–80
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2007
| (16) Niagara
| (16) Florida A&M<br />(1) Kansas
| W 77–69<br />L 67–107
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2008
| (13) Siena
| (4) Vanderbilt<br />(12) Villanova
| W 83–62<br />L 72–84
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2009
| (9) Siena
| (8) Ohio State<br />(1) Louisville
| W 74–72<br />L 72–79
|-
| 2010
| (13) Siena
| (4) Purdue
| L 64–72
|-
| 2011
| (14) Saint Peter's
| (3) Purdue
| L 43–65
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2012
| (15) Loyola (MD)<br />(14) Iona
| (2) Ohio State<br />(14) BYU
| L 59–78<br />L 72–78
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2013
| (15) Iona
| (2) Ohio State
| L 70–95
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2014
| (13) Manhattan
| (4) Louisville
| L 64–71
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2015
| (16) Manhattan
| (16) Hampton
| L 64–74
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2016
| (13) Iona
| (4) Iowa State
| L 81–94
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2017
| (14) Iona
| (3) Oregon
| L 77–93
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2018
| (15) Iona
| (2) Duke
| L 67–89
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2019
| (16) Iona
| (1) North Carolina
| L 73–88
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2021
| (15) Iona
| (2) Alabama
| L 55–68
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2022
| (15) Saint Peter's
| (2) Kentucky <br />(7) Murray State <br />(3) Purdue <br />(8) North Carolina
| W 85–79 <br />W 70–60
W 67–64 <br />L 49–69
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2023
| (13) Iona
| (4) UConn
| L 63–87
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2024
| (15) Saint Peter's
| (2) Tennessee
| L 49–83
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2025
| (16) Mount St Mary's
| (16) American <br />(1) Duke
| W 83–72 <br />L 49-93
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2026
| (16) Siena
| (1) Duke
| L 65-71
|}
| valign="top" |
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="vertical-align: middle;"
|+NIT Tournament<br/>(26–45)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1982
| Fordham<br /> Saint Peter's<br /> Iona
| Virginia Tech<br /> Syracuse<br /> Rutgers
| L 58–69<br /> L 75–84<br /> L 51–55
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1983
| Fordham<br /> Iona
| So. Florida<br /> St. Bonaventure<br /> Nebraska
| L 69–81<br /> W 90–76<br /> L 73–85
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1984
| Fordham<br /> Saint Peter's<br /> La Salle
| Weber State<br /> Tennessee<br /> Pittsburgh
| L 63–75<br /> L 40–55<br /> L 91–95
|-
| 1985
| Fordham
| Richmond
| L 57–59
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1987
| Saint Peter's<br /> La Salle
| Oklahoma<br /> Villanova<br /> Niagara<br /> Illinois St.<br /> Arkansas-LR<br /> So. Mississippi
| L 60–76<br /> W 86–84<br /> W 89–81<br /> W 70–50<br /> W 92–72<br /> L 80–84
|-
| 1988
| Fordham
| Houston
| L 61–69
|-
| 1989
| Saint Peter's
| Villanova
| L 56–76
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1990
| Holy Cross<br /> Fordham
| Rutgers<br /> Southern U.<br /> Rutgers
| L 78–87<br /> W 106–70<br /> L 74–81
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1991
| La Salle<br /> Siena
| Massachusetts<br /> Fairleigh Dickinson<br /> South Carolina<br /> Massachusetts
| L 90–93<br />W 90–85<br /> W 63–58<br /> L 80–82
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1992
| Manhattan
| Wisconsin-GB<br /> Rutgers<br /> Notre Dame
| W 67–65<br /> W 62–61<br /> L 58–74
|-
| 1993
| Niagara
| Boston College
| L 83–87
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1994
| Manhattan<br /> Canisius<br /> Siena
| Old Dominion<br /> Villanova<br /> Georgia Tech<br /> Tulane<br /> Bradley<br /> Villanova<br /> Kansas St.
| L 74–76<br /> L 79–103<br /> W 78–68<br /> W 89–79<br /> W 75–62<br /> L 58–66<br /> W 92–79
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1995
| Canisius
| Seton Hall<br /> Bradley<br /> Washington St.<br /> Virginia Tech<br /> Penn State
| W 83–71<br /> W 55–53<br /> W 89–80<br /> L 59–71<br /> L 62–66
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1996
| Iona<br /> Fairfield<br /> Manhattan
| St. Joseph's PA<br /> Providence<br /> Wisconsin
| L 78–82<br /> L 79–91<br /> L 42–55
|-
| 1997
| Iona
| Connecticut
| L 66–71
|-
| 1998
| Rider
| Penn State
| L 68–82
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2000
| Siena
| Massachusetts<br /> Penn State
| W 66–65<br /> L 103–105
|-
| 2002
| Manhattan
| Villanova
| L 69–84
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2003
| Fairfield<br /> Siena
| Boston College<br /> Villanova<br /> W. Michigan<br /> Alabama-Birm.
| L 78–90<br /> W 74–59<br /> W 68–62<br /> L 71–80
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2004
| Niagara
| Troy State<br /> Nebraska
| W 87–83<br /> L 70–78
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2006
| Manhattan
| Fairleigh Dickinson<br /> Maryland<br /> Old Dominion
| W 80–77<br /> W 87–84<br /> L 66–70
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2007
| Marist
| Oklahoma State<br /> N.C. State
| W 67–64<br /> L 62–69
|-
| 2009
| Niagara
| Rhode Island
| L 62–68
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2011
| Fairfield
| Colorado State<br /> Kent State
| W 62–60<br /> L 68–72
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2013
| Niagara
| Maryland
| L 70–86
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2014
| Iona
| Louisiana Tech
| L 88–89
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2015
| Iona
| Rhode Island
| L 75–88
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2016
| Monmouth
| Bucknell <br /> George Washington
| W 90–80 <br /> L 71–87
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2017
| Monmouth
| Ole Miss
| L 83–91
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2018
| Rider
| Oregon
| L 86–99
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2022
| Iona
| Florida
| L 74–79
|}
| valign="top" |
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="vertical-align: middle;"
|+CBI Tournament<br/>(7–8)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|-
| 2008
| Rider
| Old Dominion
| L 65–68
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2014
| Siena
| Stony Brook<br /> Penn State<br /> Illinois State<br /> Fresno State*
| W 66–55<br /> W 54–52<br /> W 61–49<br /> W 61–57<br /> L 75–89<br /> W 81–68
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2015
| Rider
| Loyola (IL)
| L 59–62
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2016
| Siena
| Morehead State
| L 80–84
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2018
| Canisius
| Jacksonville State
| L 78–80
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2024
| Quinnipiac<br /> Fairfield
| Evansville<br /> Little Rock<br /> Chicago State<br /> Seattle
| L 63–94<br /> W 82–75<br /> W 77–74<br /> L 58–75
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2025
| Manhattan
| Incarnate Word
| L 85–92
|}
'*' Best-of-three Championship Series
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="vertical-align: middle;"
|+CIT Tournament<br/>(19–18)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|-
| 2009
| Rider
| Liberty
| L 64–79
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2010
| Fairfield
| George Mason<br /> Creighton
| W 101–96<br /> L 55–73
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2011
| Rider<br /> Iona
| Northern Iowa<br /> Valparaiso<br /> Buffalo<br /> East Tennessee State<br /> Santa Clara
| L 50–84<br /> W 85–77<br /> W 78–63<br /> W 83–80<br /> L 69–76
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2012
| Manhattan<br /> <br /> Fairfield
| Albany<br /> Fairfield<br /> Yale<br /> Manhattan<br /> Robert Morris<br /> Mercer
| W 89–79<br /> L 57–69<br /> W 68–56<br /> W 69–57<br /> W 67–61<br /> L 59–64
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2013
| Canisius<br /><br /><br /> Fairfield<br /> Loyola (MD)<br /><br /><br /> Rider
| Elon<br /> Youngstown State<br /> Evansville<br /> Kent State<br /> Boston University<br /> Kent State<br /> East Carolina<br /> Hartford<br /> East Carolina
| W 69–53<br /> W 84–82<br /> L 83–84<br /> L 71–73<br /> W 70–63<br /> W 73–59<br /> L 58–70<br /> W 63–54<br /> L 54–75
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2014
| Canisius<br /> Quinnipiac
| VMI<br /> Yale
| L 100–111<br /> L 68–69
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2015
| Canisius
| Dartmouth <br /> Bowling Green <br /> NJIT
| W 87–72 <br /> W 82–59 <br /> L 73–78
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2016
| Fairfield
| New Hampshire
| L 62–77
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2017
| Canisius <br /> Fairfield <br /> Saint Peter's
| Samford <br /> UMBC <br /> Albany <br /> Texas State <br /> Furman <br /> Texas A&M–Corpus Christi
| L 74–78 <br /> L 83–88 <br /> W 59–55 <br /> W 49–44 <br /> W 77–51 <br /> W 62–61
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2018
| Niagara
| Eastern Michigan
| L 65–83
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2019
| Quinnipiac
| NJIT
| L 81–92
|}
|}
NCAA tournament at-large bids
In 2012, Iona, who was inspired by one of their all around best players Sean Armand, which had lost in the semifinals of that year's MAAC tournament, received an NCAA at-large tournament bid. This was the second time the conference was awarded multiple men's NCAA bids.
After St. Peter's won the 1995 MAAC tournament, the NCAA men's basketball tournament selection committee awarded Manhattan University an at large bid. The Jaspers proved the committee correct by defeating Oklahoma in the first round.
The same first-round success Manhattan enjoyed in the 1995 NCAA tournament could not be matched by Iona. In the 2012 NCAAs, the Gaels unexpectedly relinquished a 25-point, first-half lead to the BYU Cougars, falling 78–72 in Dayton, Ohio. Further, Iona's offense, the highest-scoring (per game) in the nation, managed just 17 points in the second half of that upset.
It was the largest comeback in NCAA tournament history, besting the 22-point hole the Duke Blue Devils rallied from to defeat the Maryland Terrapins in the Final Four of the 2001 NCAA tournament.
Women's
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|-
!Year
!Regular season champion(s)
!Tournament champion
!Player of the Year
!Defensive Player of the Year
!Coach of the Year
|-
|1982
|Saint Peter's (25–5, 5–0)
|(1) Saint Peter's
|Sheri Lauyer (Saint Peter's)
|
|Mike Granelli (Saint Peter's)
|-
|1983
|Saint Peter's (25–3, 8–1)
|(1) Saint Peter's
|Shelia Tighe (Manhattan)
|
|Dianne Nolan (Fairfield)
|-
|1984
|Saint Peter's (22–6, 9–3)
|(1) Saint Peter's
|Shelia Tighe (Manhattan)
|
|Dianne Nolan (Fairfield)
|-
|1985
|Saint Peter's (25–4, 10–2)
|(2) Holy Cross (21–7, 9–3)
|Janet Hourihan (Holy Cross)
|
|Togo Palazzi (Holy Cross)
|-
|1986
|Saint Peter's (26–3, 11–1)
|(2) La Salle (21–9, 10–2)
|Adrienne Draughn (Saint Peter's)
|
|Mike Granelli (Saint Peter's)
|-
|1987
|La Salle (21–7, 9–3)
|(5) Manhattan (20–11, 6–6)
|Tracey Quinn (Holy Cross)
|
|John Miller (La Salle)
|-
|1988
|La Salle (25–4, 11–1)
|(3) Fairfield (19–9, 8–4)
|Tracey Sneed (La Salle)
|
|John Miller (La Salle)
|-
|1989
|La Salle (27–2, 11–1)
|(2) Holy Cross (21–9, 10–2)
|Jeanine Radice (Fordham)
|
|John Miller (La Salle)
|-
|1990
|Fairfield (25–6, 15–1)
|(2) Manhattan (18–13, 8–2)
|Tonya Grant (Saint Peter's)
|
|Dianne Nolan (Fairfield)
|-
|1991
|Fairfield (25–6, 15–1)
|(1) Fairfield
|Val Higgins (Siena)
|
|Gina Castelli (Siena)
|-
|1992
|La Salle (25–5, 14–2)
|(2) Saint Peter's (24–7, 13–3)
|Jennifer Cole (La Salle)
|
|Mike Rappl (Canisius)
|-
|1993
|Niagara (17–10, 9–5)
|(2) Saint Peter's (18–11, 9–5)
|Samantha David (Niagara)
|
|Bill Agronin (Niagara)
|-
|1994
|Siena (24–4, 13–1)
|(2) Loyola (MD) (18–11, 12–2)
|Liz Lopes (Siena)
|
|Gina Castelli (Siena)
|-
|1995
|Saint Peter's (22–6, 12–2)
|(4) Loyola (MD) (20–9, 7–6)
|Patty Stoffey (Loyola (MD))
|
|Kara Rehbaum (Canisius)
|-
|1996
|Saint Peter's (23–5, 12–2)
|(2) Manhattan (19–11, 11–3)
|Gina Somma (Manhattan)
|
|Mike Granelli (Saint Peter's)
|-
|1997
|Saint Peter's (25–4, 14–0)
|(1) Saint Peter's
|Heather Fiore (Canisius)<br />Jessica Grosarth (Fairfield)
|
|Dianne Nolan (Fairfield)<br />Mike Granelli (Saint Peter's)
|-
|1998
|Siena (20–8, 16–2)
|(2) Fairfield (20–10, 14–4)
|Melanie Halker (Siena)
|
|Gina Castelli (Siena)
|-
|1999
|Siena (22–9, 16–2)
|(2) Saint Peter's (25–6, 15–3)
|Melanie Halker (Siena)
|
|Mike Granelli (Saint Peter's)
|-
|2000
|Fairfield (25–8, 15–3)
|(2) Saint Peter's (23–8, 14–4)
|Gail Strumpf (Fairfield)
|
|Dianne Nolan (Fairfield)
|-
|2001
|Siena (24–6, 17–1)
|(1) Siena
|Gunta Basko (Siena)
|
|Gina Castelli (Siena)
|-
|2002
|Siena (23–7, 16–2)
|(2) Saint Peter's (25–6, 15–3)
|Gunta Basko (Siena)
|Gunta Basko (Siena
|Sal Buscaglia (Manhattan)<br />Gina Castelli (Siena)
|-
|2003
|Manhattan (20–10, 15–3)
|(1) Manhattan
|Liene Jansone (Siena)
|Eva Cunningham (Niagara)
|Bill Agronin (Niagara)
|-
|2004
|Siena (17–11, 13–5)
|(2) Marist (20–11, 13–5)
|Jenel Stevens (Canisius)
|Jenel Stevens (Canisius)<br />Jolene Johnston (Siena)
|Brian Giorgis (Marist)
|-
|2005
|Marist (22–7, 15–3)
|(2) Canisius (21–10, 14–4)
|Eva Cunningham (Niagara)
|Alisa Kresge (Marist)<br />Lauren Surber (Siena)
|Brian Giorgis (Marist)<br />Bill Agronin (Niagara)
|-
|2006
|Marist (23–7, 16–2)
|(1) Marist
|Fifi Camara (Marist)
|Alisa Kresge (Marist)
|Anthony Bozzella (Iona)<br />Brian Giorgis (Marist)
|-
|2007
|Marist (29–6, 17–1)
|(1) Marist
|Martina Weber (Iona)
|Alisa Kresge (Marist)
|Joe Logan (Loyola (MD))
|-
|2008
|Marist (32–3, 18–0)
|(1) Marist
|Rachele Fitz (Marist)
|Tania Kennedy (Saint Peter's)
|Brian Giorgis (Marist)
|-
|2009
|Marist (29–4, 16–2)
|(1) Marist
|Rachele Fitz (Marist)
|Brittané Russell (Canisius)
|Terry Zeh (Canisius)
|-
|2010
|Marist (25–7, 15–3)
|(1) Marist
|Rachele Fitz (Marist)
|Stephanie Geehan (Fairfield)
|Kendra Faustin (Niagara)
|-
|2011
|Marist (31–3, 18–0)
|(1) Marist
|Erica Allenspach (Marist)
|Katie Sheahin (Loyola (MD))
|Brian Giorgis (Marist)
|-
|2012
|Marist (24–7, 17–1)
|(1) Marist
|Corielle Yarde (Marist)
|Katie Sheahin (Loyola (MD))
|Brian Giorgis (Marist)
|-
|2013
|Marist (23–6, 18–0)
|(1) Marist
|Damika Martinez (Iona)
|Leanne Ockenden (Marist)
|Brian Giorgis (Marist)
|-
|2014
|Iona (25–4, 18–2)
|(2) Marist (27–6, 18–2)
|Damika Martinez (Iona)
|Leanne Ockenden (Marist)
|Billi Godsey (Iona)
|-
|2015
|Quinnipiac (28–3, 20–0)
|(1) Quinnipiac
|Damika Martinez (Iona)
|Tehresa Coles (Siena)
|Tricia Fabbri (Quinnipiac)
|-
|2016
|Quinnipiac (24–8, 17–3)
|(2) Iona (23–11, 16–4)
|Tori Jarosz (Marist)
|Amani Tatum (Manhattan)
|Tricia Fabbri (Quinnipiac)
|-
|2017
|Quinnipiac (24–6, 17–3)
|(1) Quinnipiac
|Robin Perkins (Rider)
|Jackie Benitez (Siena)
|Lynn Milligan (Rider)
|-
|2018
|Quinnipiac (26–5, 17–0)
|(1) Quinnipiac
|Victoria Rampado (Niagara)
|Maura Fitzpatrick (Marist)
|Tricia Fabbri (Quinnipiac)
|-
|2019
|Quinnipiac (23–6, 18–0)
|(1) Quinnipiac
|Stella Johnson (Rider)
|Courtney Warley (Manhattan)
||Tricia Fabbri (Quinnipiac)
|-
|2020
|Rider (25–4, 18–2) <br /> Marist (25–4, 18–2)
!scope="row" style="text-align:center"|
|Stella Johnson (Rider)
|Amari Johnson (Rider)
|Lynn Milligan (Rider)
|-
|2021
|Marist (12–4, 14–2)
|(1) Marist
|Mackenzie DeWees (Quinnipiac)
|Mikala Morris (Quinnipiac)
|Brian Giorgis (Marist) <br /> Marc Mitchel (Saint Peter's)
|-
|2022
|Fairfield (25–6, 19–1)
|(1) Fairfield
|Lou Lopez Sénéchal (Fairfield)
|Juana Camilion (Iona)
|Joe Frager (Fairfield)
|-
|2023
|Iona (24-6, 18–2)
|(1) Iona
|Juana Camilion (Iona)
|Juana Camilion (Iona)
|Billi Chambers (Iona)
|-
|2024
|Fairfield (28-1, 20–0)
|(1) Fairfield
|Janelle Brown (Fairfield)
|Elisa Mevius (Siena)
|Carly Thibault-DuDonis (Fairfield)
|-
|2025
|Fairfield (28-4, 19-1)
|(1) Fairfield
|Gal Raviv (Quinnipiac)
|Ny'Ceara Pryor (Sacred Heart)
| Tricia Fabbri (Quinnipiac)
|-
|2026
|Quinnipiac (24-5, 19-1)
|(2) Fairfield (27-4, 19-1)
|Kaety L'Amoreaux (Fairfield)
|Paloma Garcia (Merrimack)
|Kelly Morrone (Merrimack)
|}
;Notes
Postseason history
{| width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
{| class= "wikitable sortable"
|+NCAA tournament<br/>(9–46)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|-
| 1982
| (8) Saint Peter's
| (1) Old Dominion
| L 42–75
|-
| 1983
| (33) La Salle
| (32) South Carolina State
| L 67–85
|-
| 1985
| (7) Holy Cross
| (2) Ohio State
| L 60–102
|-
| 1986
| (10) La Salle
| (7) Villanova
| L 55–60
|-
| 1987
| (10) Manhattan
| (7) Indiana
| L 55–70
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1988
| (10) Fairfield<br /> (8) La Salle
| (7) St. John's<br /> (9) Penn State
| L 70–83<br /> L 85–86
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1989
| (9) Holy Cross<br /> (9) La Salle
| (8) Temple<br /> (8) Connecticut<br /> (1) Tennessee
| L 80–90<br />W 72–63<br />L 61–91
|-
| 1990
| (12) Manhattan
| (5) Clemson
| L 55–79
|-
| 1991
| (12) Fairfield
| (5) Providence
| L 87–88
|-
| 1992
| (11) Saint Peter's
| (6) Connecticut
| L 66–83
|-
| 1993
| (12) Saint Peter's
| (5) Miami
| L 44–61
|-
| 1994
| (14) Loyola (MD)
| (3) Virginia
| L 47–72
|-
| 1995
| (10) Loyola (MD)
| (7) Oklahoma
| L 45–90
|-
| 1996
| (14) Manhattan
| (3) Virginia
| L 55–100
|-
| 1997
| (15) Saint Peter's
| (2) Louisiana Tech
| L 50–94
|-
| 1998
| (15) Fairfield
| (2) Connecticut
| L 52–93
|-
| 1999
| (13) Saint Peter's
| (4) Virginia Tech
| L 48–73
|-
| 2000
| (14) Saint Peter's
| (3) Mississippi State
| L 60–94
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2001
| (11) Siena<br /> (12) Fairfield
| (6) Colorado<br /> (5) Utah
| L 57–79<br /> L 78–98
|-
| 2002
| (11) Saint Peter's
| (6) Cincinnati
| L 63–76
|-
| 2003
| (14) Manhattan
| (3) Mississippi State
| L 47–73
|-
| 2004
| (14) Marist
| (3) Oklahoma
| L 45–58
|-
| 2005
| (15) Canisius
| (2) Duke
| L 48–80
|-
| 2006
| (14) Marist
| (3) Georgia
| L 60–75
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2007
| (13) Marist
| (4) Ohio State<br /> (5) Middle Tennessee<br /> (1) Tennessee
| W 67–63<br /> W 73–59<br /> L 46–65
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2008
| (7) Marist
| (10) DePaul<br /> (2) LSU
| W 76–57<br /> L 49–68
|-
| 2009
| (12) Marist
| (5) Virginia
| L 61–68
|-
| 2010
| (12) Marist
| (5) Georgetown
| L 42–62
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2011
| (10) Marist
| (7) Iowa State<br /> (2) Duke
| W 74–64 <br /> L 66–71
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2012
| (13) Marist
| (4) Georgia<br /> (5) St. Bonaventure
| W 76–70 <br /> L 63–66
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2013
| (12) Marist
| (5) Michigan State
| L 47–55
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2014
| (11) Marist
| (6) Iowa
| L 65–87
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2015
| (12) Quinnipiac
| (5) Oklahoma
| L 84–111
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2016
| (15) Iona
| (2) Maryland
| L 58–74
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2017
| (12) Quinnipiac
| (5) Marquette <br /> (4) Miami (FL) <br /> (1) South Carolina
| W 68–65 <br /> W 85–78 <br /> L 58–100
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2018
| (9) Quinnipiac
| (8) Miami (FL) <br /> (1) Connecticut
| W 86–72 <br /> L 46–71
|-
| 2019
| (11) Quinnipiac
| (6) South Dakota State
| L 65–76
|-
| 2021
| (15) Marist
| (2) Louisville
| L 43–74
|-
| 2022
| (15) Fairfield
| (2) Texas
| L 52–70
|-
| 2023
| (14) Iona
| (3) Duke
| L 49–89
|-
| 2024
| (13) Fairfield
| (4) Indiana
| L 56–89
|-
| 2025
| (12) Fairfield
| (5) Kansas State
| L 85–41
|-
| 2026
| (11) Fairfield
| (6) Notre Dame
| L 60-79
|}
| valign="top" |
{| class= "wikitable sortable"
|+WNIT Tournament<br/>(8–23)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 1999
| Siena
| Georgetown<br /> Wisconsin
| W 86–73<br /> L 85–107
|-
| 2000
| Fairfield
| Wisconsin
| L 46–82
|-
| 2002
| Siena
| St. Joseph's (PA)
| L 55–84
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2003
| Siena
| Seton Hall<br /> Creighton
| W 66–58<br /> L 86–96
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2007
| Iona
| Long Island<br /> Indiana
| W 91–79<br /> L 71–74
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2008
| Iona
| Quinnipiac<br /> St. John's
| W 71–59<br /> L 59–65
|-
| 2009
| Canisius
| Syracuse
| L 65–90
|-
| 2010
| Iona
| Maryland
| L 53–88
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2011
| Loyola (MD)
| Old Dominion <br /> Virginia
| W 67–65<br /> L 49–71
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2012
| Fairfield
| Drexel
| L 41–57
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2013
| Iona
| Drexel
| L 50–59
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2014
| Iona<br /> Quinnipiac
| Harvard<br /> Villanova
| L 89–90<br /> L 66–74
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2015
| Marist
| Temple
| L 54–67
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2016
| Quinnipiac
| Maine <br /> Temple
| W 90–43 <br /> L 64–62
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2017
| Rider
| Virginia Tech
| L 62–76
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2018
| Marist
| St. John's
| L 47–68
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2019
| Rider
| West Virginia
| L 43–83
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2022
| Quinnipiac
| Rhode Island <br />Boston College
| W 61–50 <br /> L 68–94
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2023
| Niagara
| Green Bay
| L 52–84
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2024
| Niagara
| Le Moyne<br /> Vermont
| W 91-86<br /> L 63–69
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2025
| Siena
| Howard
| L 62–72
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2026
| Merrimack
| NJIT
| L 65-68
|}
| valign="top" |
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="vertical-align: middle;"
|+WBI Tournament<br/>(12–9)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2010
| Fairfield
| Towson<br /> Appalachian State
| W 69–55<br /> L 36–59
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2011
| Manhattan
| Sacred Heart<br /> Wright State<br /> UAB
| W 52–48<br /> W 75–73<br /> L 43–62
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2012
| Manhattan
| Robert Morris<br /> Holy Cross<br /> Minnesota
| W 77–54 <br /> W 78–63<br /> L 54–67
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2013
| Fairfield
| St. Francis <br /> Pennsylvania
| W 71–51 <br /> L 48–49
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2014
| Fairfield
| Bryant<br /> Maine<br /> UIC
| W 90–86<br /> W 63–50<br /> L 44–74
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2015
| Siena
| Stony Brook <br /> Xavier <br /> Mercer <br /> Louisiana Lafayette
| W 53–46 <br /> W 69–49 <br /> W 65–54 <br /> L 50–52
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2016
| Fairfield
| UMBC
| L 49–61
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2021
| Manhattan
| Cleveland State <br /> Loyola-Chicago <br /> FIU
| L 55–68 <br /> W 56–51 <br /> L 58–59
|}
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="vertical-align: middle;"
|+WBIT Tournament<br/>(1–2)
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2025
| Quinnipiac
| Seton Hall
| L 40-57
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
| 2026
| Quinnipiac
| George Mason <br /> Stanford
| W 64-71 <br /> L 69-81
|}
|}
Baseball
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
Champions
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
!Year
!Champion(s)
|-
|1982
|Army
|-
|1983
|Fairfield
|-
|1984
|Iona
|-
|1985
|LaSalle
|-
|1986
|Holy Cross
|-
|1987
|Fordham
|-
|1988
|Fordham
|-
|1989
|LaSalle
|-
|1990
|Le Moyne~<br />Fordham^
|-
|1991
|Le Moyne~<br />Fairfield^
|-
|1992
|Le Moyne~<br />Iona^
|-
|1993
|Le Moyne~<br />Fairfield^
|-
|1994
|Saint Peter's
|-
|1995
|Siena
|-
|1996
|Siena
|-
|1997
|Siena
|-
|1998
|Le Moyne
|-
|1999
|Siena
|-
|2000
|Marist
|-
|2001
|Marist
|-
|2002
|Marist
|-
|2003
|Le Moyne
|-
|2004
|Le Moyne
|-
|2005
|Marist
|-
|2006
|Manhattan
|-
|2007
|Le Moyne
|-
|2008
|Rider
|-
|2009
|Marist
|-
|2010
|Rider
|-
|2011
|Manhattan
|-
|2012
|Manhattan
|-
|2013
|Canisius
|-
|2014
|Siena
|-
|2015
|Canisius
|-
|2016
|Fairfield
|-
|2017
|Marist
|-
|2018
|Canisius
|-
|2019
|Quinnipiac
|-
|2020
|Canceled due to COVID-19
|-
|2021
|Rider
|-
|2022
|Canisius
|-
|2023
|Rider
|-
|2024
|Niagara
|-
|2025
|Fairfield
|-
|2026
|Rider
|}
From 1990 through 1993, the MAAC, split into two divisions.<br />
~North Division Champion<br />
^South Division Champion
| valign="top" |
Postseason history
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
{| class=wikitable
<CAPTION ALIGN=TOP>NCAA tournament<br/>(10–54)</CAPTION>
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1997
|Marist
|Florida State<br /> Western Carolina
|L 2–4<br /> L 3–8
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1999
|Siena
|Wake Forest<br /> Virginia Tech
|L 4–22<br /> L 5–11
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2000
|Marist
|East Carolina<br /> McNeese State<br />East Carolina
|L 3–12<br /> W 6–5<br /> L 7–8
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2001
|Marist
|Stanford<br />Long Beach State<br />Stanford
|L 3–4<br /> W 7–6<br /> L 0–6
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2002
|Marist
|SW Missouri State<br />Nebraska<br />SW Missouri State
|W 5–4*<br /> L 1–9<br /> L 2–5
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2003
|Le Moyne
|North Carolina State<br />Western Carolina
|L 2–8<br />L 5–9
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2004
|Le Moyne
|Arkansas<br /> Missouri
|L 1–4<br /> L 3–11
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2005
|Marist
|LSU<br /> Northwestern State
|L 5–14<br /> L 3–4
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2006
|Manhattan
|Nebraska<br /> Miami<br /> San Francisco<br /> Miami
|W 4–1<br /> L 2–8<br /> W 6–4<br /> L 4–10
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2007
|Le Moyne
|Texas A&M<br /> Ohio State
|L 2–7<br /> L 5–6*
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2008
|Rider
|Cal State Fullerton<br /> Virginia
|L 0–11<br /> L 2–8
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2009
|Marist
|Florida State<br /> Ohio State
|L 4–16<br /> L 4–6
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2010
|Rider
|Texas<br /> Rice
|L 0–11<br /> L 1–19
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2011
|Manhattan
|Florida<br /> Jacksonville
|L 3–17<br /> L 4–5
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2012
|Manhattan
|South Carolina<br /> Coastal Carolina
|L 0–7<br /> L 1–11
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2013
|Canisius
|North Carolina<br /> Florida Atlantic
|L 3–6<br /> L 6–14
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2014
|Siena
|TCU<br /> Dallas Baptist<br /> Sam Houston St.
|L 1–2<br /> W 9–8<br /> L 2–9
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2015
|Canisius
|Missouri State <br /> Oregon
|L 1–14 <br /> L 6–12
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2016
|Fairfield
|Texas Tech <br /> Dallas Baptist
|L 1–12 <br /> L 5–8
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2017
|Marist
|Florida <br /> Bethune-Cookman
|L 6–10 <br /> L 2–4
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2018
|Canisius
|Minnesota <br /> Gonzaga
|L 1–10 <br /> L 2–8
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2019
|Quinnipiac
|East Carolina <br /> Campbell <br /> East Carolina
|W 5–4 <br /> L 8–9 <br /> L 3–13
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2021
|Rider <br /> <br /> Fairfield
|Louisiana Tech <br /> Alabama <br /> Arizona State <br /> Southern <br /> Arizona State <br /> Texas
|L 2–18 <br /> L 1–3 <br /> L 6–7 <br /> W 6–2 <br /> W 9–7 <br /> L 2–12
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2022
|Canisius
|Miami <br /> Arizona
|L 6-11 <br /> L 5-7
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2023
|Rider
|Coastal Carolina <br /> Duke <br /> Coastal Carolina
|W 11-10* <br /> L 1-2 <br /> L 5-13
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2024
|Niagara
|Oklahoma St. <br /> Nebraska
|L 7-19 <br /> L 5-7
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2025
|Fairfield
|Coastal Carolina <br /> Florida
|L 2-10 <br /> L 2-17
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2026
|Rider
|Florida <br />
|
|}
'*' Extra Innings
|}
|}
Softball
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
Champions
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
!Year
!Champion(s)
|-
|1984
|Iona
|-
|1985
|Iona
|-
|1986
|Army
|-
|1987
|LaSalle
|-
|1988
|Army
|-
|1989
|LaSalle
|-
|1990
|LaSalle
|-
|1991
|Fairfield
|-
|1992
|LaSalle
|-
|1993
|Canisius
|-
|1994
|Canisius
|-
|1995
|Canisius
|-
|1996
|Canisius
|-
|1997
|Canisius
|-
|1998
|Niagara
|-
|1999
|Manhattan
|-
|2000
|Canisius
|-
|2001
|Saint Peter's
|-
|2002
|Canisius
|-
|2003
|Rider
|-
|2004
|Canisius
|-
|2005
|Canisius
|-
|2006
|Marist
|-
|2007
|Canisius
|-
|2008
|Canisius
|-
|2009
|Canisius
|-
|2010
|Iona
|-
|2011
|Iona
|-
|2012
|Iona
|-
|2013
|Marist
|-
|2014
|Iona
|-
|2015
|Fairfield
|-
|2016
|Marist
|-
|2017
|Fairfield
|-
|2018
|Monmouth
|-
|2019
|Monmouth
|-
|2020
|Canceled due to COVID-19
|-
|2021
|Manhattan
|-
|2022
|Canisius
|-
|2023
|Marist
|-
|2024
|Siena
|-
|2025
|Marist
|-
|2026
|Marist
|}
| valign="top" |
Postseason history
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
{| class=wikitable
<CAPTION ALIGN=TOP>NCAA tournament<br/>(4–58)</CAPTION>
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1994
|Canisius
|Arizona <br /> Rutgers <br /> Texas Tech
|L 0–7 <br /> W 4-3*<br /> L 1–5
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1998
|Niagara
|Arizona <br /> Hawaii
|L 0–14 <br /> L 1–5
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1999
|Manhattan
|Southwestern Louisiana <br /> LIU Brooklyn
|L 0–15 <br /> L 3–4*
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2000
|Canisius
|UCLA <br /> Bethune-Cokkman <br /> Iowa
|L 0–8 <br /> W 3–2*<br /> L 1–2*
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2001
|Saint Peter's
|Arizona <br /> Texas Tech
|L 2-4 <br /> L 2-3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2002
|Canisius
|Michigan <br /> Central Michigan
|L 0-5 <br /> L 0-3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2003
|Rider
|Cal State Fullerton <br /> San Diego
|L 0–3 <br /> L 1–2
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2004
|Canisius
|Michigan <br /> DePaul
|L 3–6<br /> L 0–8
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2005
|Canisius
|Michigan<br /> North Carolina
|L 1–8 <br /> L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2006
|Marist
|Arizona <br /> Auburn
|L 0-9 <br /> L 0-14
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2007
|Canisius
|Virginia Tech <br /> Cal State Fullerton
|L 0-5 <br /> L 0-8
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2008
|Canisius
|Arizona <br /> Long Island <br /> Hofstra
|L 0–11 <br /> W 3-2 <br /> L 1–5
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2009
|Canisius
|Ohio State <br /> Kentucky
|L 2-3 <br /> L 0–7
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2010
|Iona
|Texas <br /> East Carolina
|L 0–6 <br /> L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2011
|Iona
|Oklahoma <br /> Missouri State
|L 1–7 <br /> L 2–4
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2012
|Iona
|California <br /> Boston University
|L 0–8 <br /> L 3–4
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2013
|Marist
|Oklahoma<br /> Forham
|L 0–17 <br /> L 3–5
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2014
|Iona
|Washington <br /> Northwestern
|L 0–8 <br /> L 4–14
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2015
|FairField
|Alabama <br /> USC Upstate
|L 0–8 <br /> L 0–9
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2016
|Marist
|Tennessee <br /> Ohio State
|L 2–10 <br /> L 1–6
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2017
|Fairfield
|LSU <br /> McNeese State
|L 1–2 <br /> L 2–6
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2018
|Monmouth
|Tennessee <br /> Ohio
|L 0–9 <br /> L 0–4
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2019
|Monmouth
|LSU<br /> Louisiana Tech
|L 0–2 <br /> L 0–1
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2021
|Manhattan
|Arkansas <br /> Stanford
|L 0–8 <br /> L 2–11
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2022
|Canisius
|Florida <br /> Wisconsin
|L 1-10 <br /> L 0-3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2023
|Marist
|Florida State <br /> South Carolina
|L 0-9 <br /> L 1-2
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2024
|Siena
|Texas <br /> Saint Francis (PA)
|L 0-5 <br /> L 0-1
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2025
|Marist
|Liberty <br /> Saint Francis <br /> Texas A&M
|L 5-10 <br /> W 8-0 <br /> L 4-17
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |\
|2026
|Marist
|Texas Tech <br /> Boston University
|L 3-10 <br /> L 2-10
|}
'*' Extra Innings
|}
|}
Soccer
Men's
{| class="wikitable"
! width="40"|Year
! width="275"|Regular Season Champ
! width="100"|Tournament Champ
! width="200"|Offensive/Overall Player the Year/Golden Boot
! width="200"|Defensive of the Year
! width="200"|Goalkeeper of the Year/Golden Gloves
! width="210"|Coach of the Year
|-
| 1988
| Army (13–5–1 overall, 6–1–0 MAAC)
| Army
|David Hauck (Army)
|
|
|Joe Chiavaro (Army)
|-
| 1989
| Loyola (10–5–2 overall, 5–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
|John Brence (Army)
|
|
|Bill Sento (Loyola)
|-
| 1990
| Loyola (16–2–5 overall, 8–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
|Doug Miller (Loyola)
|
|
|Bill Sento (Loyola)
|-
| 1991
| Loyola (12–8–2 overall, 8–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
|Tom Donahue (Loyola)
|
|
| Dejan Cokic (Fairfield)
|-
| 1992
| Loyola (16–4–1 overall, 6–1–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Jim McElderry (Fairfield)
|
|
| Dejan Cokic (Fairfield)
|-
| 1993
| Loyola (19–3–1 overall, 7–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
|Jim McElderry (Fairfield)
|
|
|Bill Sento (Loyola)
|-
| 1994
| Loyola (15–5–2 overall, 6–1–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
|Bill Wnek (Loyola)
|
|
|Gerry McKeown (Saint Peter's)
|-
| 1995
| Loyola (15–6–0 overall, 7–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
|Chris Doyle (Loyola)
|
|
|Bobby Herodes (Iona)
|-
| 1996
| Canisius (5–12–2 overall, 4–1–2 MAAC)
| Loyola
|Tony Burke (Canisius)
|
|
|Paul James (Niagara)
|-
| 1997
| Rider (15–6–1 overall, 8–1–0 MAAC)
| Rider
| Craig Wicken (Rider)
|
|
|Mike Jacobs (Marist)
|-
| 1998
| Fairfield (15–4–1 overall, 7–1–1 MAAC)
| Rider
| Christof Lindenmayer (Loyola)
Craig Wicken (Rider)
|
|
| Carl Rees (Fairfield)
|-
| 1999
| Loyola (13–6–2 overall, 7–1–1 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Christof Lindenmayer (Loyola)
|
|
| Bill Sento (Loyola)
|-
| 2000
| Loyola (12–4–2 overall, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Marist
| Joseph Crespo (Marist)
|
|
|Mark Mettrick, Loyola
|-
| 2001
| Loyola (17–2–2 overall, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Niall Lepper (Loyola)
|
|Reb Beatty (Loyola)
| Mark Mettrick (Loyola)
|-
| 2002
| Loyola (13–5–3 overall, 8–0–1 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Niall Lepper (Loyola)
|
|Reb Beatty (Loyola)
| Bobby Herodes (Marist)
|-
| 2003
| Loyola (11–7–3 overall, 6–2–1 MAAC)
| Saint Peter's
| Omar Alfonso (Loyola)
| Alex Cunliffe (Fairfield)
Fabian Lewis (Canisius)
|
| Cesar Markovic (Saint Peter's)
|-
| 2004
| Loyola (11–6–1 overall, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Marist
| Douglas Narvaez (Saint Peter's)
| Ben Castor (Marist)
|
| Mark Mettrick (Loyola)
|-
| 2005
| Fairfield (13–4–3 overall, 8–0–1 MAAC)
| Marist
| Matt Stedman (Niagara)
| Ben Castor (Marist)
|
| Dermot McGrane (Niagara)
|-
| 2006
| Fairfield (15–6–1 overall, 7–2–0 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Juan Gaviria (Saint Peter's)
| Tom Skara (Fairfield)
|
| Dermot McGrane (Niagara)
|-
| 2007
| Loyola 19–3–1 overall, 8–1–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Murphy Wiredu (Saint Peter's)
| Tennant McVea (Loyola)
|
| Mark Mettrick (Loyola)
|-
| 2008
| Loyola (18–2–1 overall, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Jamie Darvill (Loyola)
| Tennant McVea (Loyola)
|
| Mark Mettrick (Loyola)
|-
| 2009
| Iona (14–2–2 overall, 8–1–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Jamie Darvill (Loyola)
| Tennant McVea (Loyola)
|
| Fernando Barboto (Iona)
|-
| 2010
| Saint Peter's (13–6–1 overall, 7–1–1 MAAC)
| Saint Peter's
| Emery Welshman (Siena)
| Assaf Sheleg (Saint Peter's)
|
| Guy Abrahamson (Saint Peter's)
|-
| 2011
| Fairfield (12–5–1 overall, 8–0–1 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Carl Haworth (Niagara)
| Michael O'Keeffe (Fairfield)
|
| Carl Rees (Fairfield)
|-
| 2012
| Loyola (13–6–1 overall, 7–1–1 MAAC)
| Niagara
| Sindre Ek (Siena)
| Rene DeZorzi (Niagara)
| Brett Petricek (Niagara)
| Gareth Elliott (Siena)
|-
| 2013
| Monmouth (8–6–5 overall, 7–1–2 MAAC)
| Quinnipiac
| Franklin Castellanos (Iona)
| Matt Jeffery (Monmouth)
| Borja Angoitia (Quinnipiac)
| Jorden Scott (Manhattan)
|-
| 2014
| Quinnipiac (10–4–5 overall, 7–0–3 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Ignacio Maganto (Iona)
| Matt Jeffery (Monmouth)
| Borja Angoitia (Quinnipiac)
| Eric Da Costa (Quinnipiac)
|-
| 2015
| Monmouth (11–3–4 overall, 7–0–3 MAAC)
| Rider
| Marcos Nunez (Iona)
| David Acuna Camacho (Monmouth)
| Eric Klenofsky (Monmouth)
| Robert McCourt (Monmouth)
|-
| 2016
| Quinnipiac (13–7–0 overall, 8–2–0 MAAC)
| Rider
| Cameron Harr (Marist)
| Thomas Teupen (Canisius)
| Eric Klenofsky (Monmouth)<br /> Ryan Baird (Rider)
| Eric Da Costa (Quinnipiac)
|-
| 2017
| Fairfield (12–4–3 overall, 7–1–2 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Allen Gavilanes (Marist)
| Alex Grattarola (Canisius)
| Marcellin Gohier (Manhattan)
| Carl Rees (Fairfield)
|-
| 2018
| Fairfield (11–5–2 overall, 8–0–2 MAAC)
| Rider
| Eamon Whelan (Quinnipiac)
| Jonas Vergin (Fairfield)
| Gordon Botterill (Fairfield)
| Carl Rees (Fairfield)
|-
| 2019
| Saint Peter's (13–6 overall, 9–1 MAAC)
| Iona
| Dominic Laws (Saint Peter's)
| Malcolm Moreno (Iona)
| Samuel Ilin (Marist)
| Julian Richens (Saint Peter's)
|-
| 2020^
| Quinnipiac (7–2 overall, 5–1 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Dominic Laws (Saint Peter's)
| George Akampeke (Monmouth)
| Sean Murray (Monmouth) <br /> Jared Mazzola (Quinnipiac) <br /> Gordon Botterill (Fairfield)
| Robert McCourt (Monmouth)
|-
| 2021
| Marist (12–6–3 overall, 7–2-1 MAAC)
| Marist
| Zaki Alibou (Rider)
| Huib Achterkamp (Marist)
| Sam Ilin (Marist)
| Matt Viggiano (Marist)
|-
| 2022
| Quinnipiac (11-4-3 overall, 8–0-1 MAAC)
| Quinnipiac
| David Bercedo (Quinnipiac)
| Nassim Akki (Manhattan)
| Greg Monroe (Siena)
| Eric Da Costa (Quinnipiac)
|-
| 2023
| Iona (12-4 overall, 9-1 MAAC)
| Rider
| Camil Azzam Ruiz (Iona)
| Tim Timchenko (Iona)
| Nacho Alfaro Monge (Iona)
| James Hamilton (Iona)
|-
| 2024
| Iona (8-4-3 overall, 6-1-1 MAAC) <br /> Rider (12-4-1 overall, 6-1-1 MAAC)
| Iona
| Momo Diop (Rider)
| Tim Timchenko (Iona)
| Adam Salama (Rider)
| Chad Duernberger (Rider)
|-
| 2025
| Sacred Heart (8-3-5 overall, 7-0-3 MAAC)
| Siena
| Tim Strele (Saint Peter's)
| Daniel Losfablos (Sacred Heart)
| Luca Marinelli (Sacred Heart)
| Anthony Anzevui (Sacred Heart)
|}
^ Tournament delayed until April 2021 due to Covid
Women's
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! width="40"|Year
! width="275"|Regular Season Champ
! width="100"|Tournament Champ
! width="200"|Overall/Offensive Player of the Year/Golden Boot
! width="200"|Defensive of the Year
! width="200"|Goalkeeper of the Year/Golden Glove
! width="200"|Coach of the Year
|-
| 1992
|
| Iona
|
|
|
|
|-
| 1993
|
| Fairfield
| Stacy Wagenseil (Canisius)
|
|
| Debbie Belkin (Fairfield)
|-
| 1994
| Loyola (11–10–0 overall, 6–1–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Stacy Wagenseil (Canisius)<br /> Val Kujan (Siena)
|
|
| Glenn Crooks (Saint Peter's)<br /> Dave Gerrity (Loyola)
|-
| 1995
| Loyola (10–6–4 overall, 6–1–0 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Kelli Hurley (Fairfield)
| Erin Gilroy (Loyola)
|
| Dave Gerrity (Loyola)
|-
| 1996
|
| Loyola
| Nicole Tracey (Saint Peter's)
| Erin Gilroy (Loyola)
|
| Scott Sylvester (Saint Peter's)
|-
| 1997
|
| Fairfield
| Abby Allen (Fairfield)
|
|
| Maria Piechocki (Fairfield)
|-
| 1998
|
| Fairfield
| Abby Allen (Fairfield)
|
|
| Maria Piechocki (Fairfield)
|-
| 1999
| Loyola (13–4–1 overall, 8–0–1 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Pam Cluff (Fairfield)
| Julie Kapcala (Loyola)
|
| Peter Veltri (Niagara)
|-
| 2000
| Loyola (15–5–0, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Pam Cluff (Fairfield)
| Julie Kapcala (Loyola)
|
| Joe Mallia (Loyola)
|-
| 2001
|
| Loyola
| Julie Anne Forman (Fairfield)
|
|
| Megan McGonagle (Marist)<br /> Steve Karbowski (Siena)
|-
| 2002
| Fairfield (9–7–3 overall, 8–0–1 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Rosie Luzak (Niagara)
|Noel Cox (Siena)
|
| Steve Karbowski (Siena)
|-
| 2003
| Loyola (12–9–1 overall, 8–0–1 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Tami Coyle (Rider)
| Lindsay Tracey (Loyola)<br /> Katy Owings (Niagara)
|
| Peter Veltri (Niagara)
|-
| 2004
| Loyola (16–4–0 overall, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Ali Andrzejewski (Loyola)
| Lisa Jaffa (Loyola)<br /> Noel Cox (Siena)
|
| Emma Hayes (Iona)
|-
| 2005
| Loyola (15–5–0 overall, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Ali Andrzejewski (Loyola)
| Sarra Moller (Loyola)
|
| Peter Veltri (Niagara)
|-
| 2006
| Loyola (10–7–2 overall, 8–1–0 MAAC)
| Niagara
| Kristen Turner (Siena)
| Brett Maron (Fairfield)
|
| John Byford (Loyola)
|-
| 2007
| Marist (11–5–3 overall, 7–1–1 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Brittany Bisnott (Niagara)
| Brittany Henderson (Loyola)
|
| Elizabeth Roper (Marist)
|-
| 2008
| Loyola (10–6–4 overall, 7–0–2 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Ahna Johnson (Fairfield)
| Sarra Moller (Loyola)
|
| Jim Wendling (Canisius)
|-
| 2009
| Loyola (13–4–3 overall, 9–0–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Theresa Ferraina (Loyola)
| Brittany Henderson (Loyola)
|
| Katherine Vettori (Loyola)
|-
| 2010
| Canisius (14–7–0 overall, 7–2–0 MAAC)
| Siena
| Kelly Reinwald (Canisius) <br /> Nichole Schiro (Loyola)
| Ashleigh Bowers (Niagara)
|
| Drayson Hounsome (Rider)
|-
| 2011
| Marist (13–6–2 overall, 7–1–1 MAAC)
| Marist
| Nichole Schiro (Loyola)
| Kelly Boudreau (Fairfield)
|
| Katherine Lyn (Marist)
|-
| 2012
| Marist (15–7–0 overall, 8–1–0 MAAC)
| Loyola
| Nichole Schiro (Loyola)
| Alli Walsh (Fairfield)
| Didi Haracic (Loyola)
| Jim O'Brien (Fairfield)
|-
| 2013
| Monmouth (16–1–2 overall, 8–0–2 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Dana Costello (Monmouth)
| Emma Pichl (Fairfield)
| Ashley Lewis (Monmouth)
| Krissy Turner (Monmouth)
|-
| 2014
| Monmouth(14–5–0 overall, 9–1–0 MAAC)
| Rider
| Tara Ballay (Rider)
| Alexa Freguletti (Monmouth)
| Taylor Booth (Siena)
| Krissy Turner (Monmouth)
|-
| 2015
| Monmouth(15–4–2 overall, 9–1–0 MAAC)
| Siena
| Alexis McTamney (Monmouth)
| Jenny Bitzer (Manhattan)
| Kristen Skonieczny (Manhattan)
| Brendan Lawler (Manhattan)
|-
| 2016
| Monmouth(14–5–2 overall, 9–0–1 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Alexis McTamney (Monmouth)
| Tara Sobierjaski (Siena)
| Bethany-May Howard (Rider)
| Krissy Turner (Monmouth)
|-
| 2017
| Monmouth(14–5–2 overall, 9–0–1 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Erica Modena (Manhattan)
| Gabriella Cuevas (Monmouth)
| Amanda Knaub (Monmouth)
| Krissy Turner (Monmouth)
|-
| 2018
| Monmouth(16–4–1 overall, 9–1–0 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Madie Gibson (Monmouth)
| Jessica Johnson (Monmouth)
| Taylor Dorado (Siena)
| Leigh Howard (Marist)
|-
| 2019
| Monmouth(14-2-3 overall, 10–0 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Lexie Palladino (Monmouth)
| Anna Lazur (Monmouth)
| Amanda Knaub (Monmouth)
| David Barrett (Fairfield)
|-
| 2020^
| Siena (6-0-2 overall, 4–0-1 MAAC)
| Siena
| Makenzie Rodrigues (Rider) <br /> Lauren Karabin (Monmouth)
| Sarina Jones (Monmouth) <br /> Brianna Montinard (Siena)
| Leslie Adams (Siena)
| Steve Karbowski (Siena)
|-
| 2021
| Monmouth (15-4-1 overall, 8-1-1 MAAC)
| Monmouth
| Florence Vaillancourt (Niagara)
| Sarina Jones (Monmouth)
| Natalie Kelchner (Marist)
| Dr. Krissy Turner (Monmouth)
|-
| 2022
| Quinnipiac (15-2-1 overall, 9-1-0 MAAC) <br /> Fairfield (14-4-0 overall, 9-1-0 MAAC)
| Quinnipiac
| Rebecca Cooke (Quinnipiac)
| Maddie Mills (FairField)
| Ellie Sciancalepore (Rider)
| Ryan Louis (Canisius)
|-
| 2023
| Quinnipiac (13-4-1 overall, 9-0-1 MAAC)
| Quinnipiac
| Courtney Chochol (Quinnipiac)
| Markela Bejleri, Kayla Mingachos, Olivia Scott (Quinnipiac)
| Sofia Lospinoso (Quinnipiac)
| Dave Clarke (Quinnipiac)
|-
| 2024
| Fairfield (15-2-1 overall, 10-1-1 MAAC)
| Fairfield
| Maddy Theriault (Fairfield)
| Alicia Zamora (Canisius)
| Sofia Lospinoso (Quinnipiac)
| David Barrett (Fairfield)
|-
| 2025
| Fairfield (15-1-2 overall, 10-0-2 MAAC)
| Sacred Heart
| Maddy Theriault (Fairfield)
| Meghan Carragher (Fairfield)
| Katie Wright (Fairfield)
| David Barrett (Fairfield)
|}
^ Tournament delayed until April 2021 due to Covid
Lacrosse
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
Men's
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center;"
!Year
!Champion
|-
|2000
|St. Joseph's
|-
|2001
|Mount Saint Mary's
|-
|2002
|Manhattan
|-
|2003
|Mount Saint Mary's (2)
|-
|2004
|Providence
|-
|2005
|Marist
|-
|2006
|Providence (2)
|-
|2007
|Providence (3)
|-
|2008
|Canisius
|-
|2009
|Siena
|-
|2010
|Mount Saint Mary's (3)
|-
|2011
|Siena (2)
|-
|2012
|Canisius (2)
|-
|2013
|Detroit Mercy
|-
|2014
|Siena (3)
|-
|2015
|Marist (2)
|-
|2016
|Quinnipiac
|-
|2017
|Monmouth
|-
|2018
|Canisius (3)
|-
|2019
|Marist (3)
|-
|2020
|Not Awarded
|-
|2021
|Monmouth (2)
|-
|2022
|Manhattan (2)
|-
|2022
|Manhattan (2)
|-
|2023
|Marist (4)
|-
|2024
|Sacred Heart
|-
|2025
|Siena (4)
|-
|2026
|Marist (5)
|}
| valign="top" |
Women's
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center;"
!Year
!Champion
|-
|2000
|Manhattan
|-
|2001
|Fairfield
|-
|2002
|Le Moyne
|-
|2003
|Le Moyne (2)
|-
|2004
|Manhattan (2)
|-
|2005
|Manhattan (3)
|-
|2006
|Le Moyne (3)
|-
|2007
|Le Moyne (4)
|-
|2008
|Marist
|-
|2009
|Fairfield (2)
|-
|2010
|Marist (2)
|-
|2011
|Canisius
|-
|2012
|Canisius (2)
|-
|2013
|Canisius (3)
|-
|2014
|Canisius (4)
|-
|2015
|Fairfield (3)
|-
|2016
|Canisius (5)
|-
|2017
|Canisius (6)
|-
|2018
|Fairfield (4)
|-
|2019
|Fairfield (5)
|-
|2020
|Not Awarded
|-
|2021
|Fairfield (6)
|-
|2022
|Fairfield (7)
|-
|2023
|Fairfield (8)
|-
|2024
|Niagara
|-
|2025
|Fairfield (9)
|-
|2026
|Fairfield (10)
|}
|}
|}
Swimming and diving
Conference champions
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center;"
!Year
!Men's champion
!Women's champion
|-
|1984
|La Salle
|La Salle
|-
|1985
|La Salle
|Army
|-
|1986
|La Salle
|La Salle
|-
|1987
|Army
|Army
|-
|1988
|Army
|Army
|-
|1989
|La Salle
|Army
|-
|1990
|La Salle
|Army
|-
|1991
|La Salle
|La Salle
|-
|1992
|La Salle
|La Salle
|-
|1993
|Iona
|Loyola
|-
|1994
|Niagara
|Loyola
|-
|1995
|Loyola
|Loyola
|-
|1996
|Marist
|Loyola
|-
|1997
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|1998
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|1999
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|2000
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|2001
|Marist
|Rider
|-
|2002
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|2003
|Marist
|Rider
|-
|2004
|Rider
|Marist
|-
|2005
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|2006
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|2007
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|2008
|Marist
|Marist
|-
|2009
|Loyola
|Rider
|-
|2010
|Loyola
|Marist
|-
|2011
|Loyola
|Marist
|-
|2012
|Rider
|Marist
|-
|2013
|Rider
|Marist
|-
|2014
|Rider
|Marist
|-
|2015
|Rider
|Marist
|-
|2016
|Rider
|Marist
|-
|2017
|Rider
|Marist
|-
|2018
|Rider
|Fairfield
|-
|2019
|Rider
|Fairfield
|-
|2020
|Rider
|Fairfield
|-
|2022
|Rider
|Niagara
|-
|2023
|Rider
|Fairfield
|-
|2024
|Marist
|Niagara
|-
|2025
|Niagara
|Niagara
|-
|2026
|Fairfield
|Fairfield
|}
Cross country
Champions
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
!Year
!Men's champion
!Women's champion
|-
|1981
|Iona
|
|-
|1982
|Iona
|
|-
|1983
|Iona
|Holy Cross
|-
|1984
|La Salle
| Holy Cross
|-
|1985
|Iona
|Holy Cross
|-
|1986
|Army
|Manhattan
|-
|1987
|Army
|Fordham
|-
|1988
|Iona
|Fordham
|-
|1989
|La Salle
|Fordham
|-
|1990
|La Salle
|Canisius
|-
|1991
|Iona
|Canisius
|-
|1992
|Iona
|Canisius
|-
|1993
|Iona
|Manhattan
|-
|1994
|Iona
|Manhattan
|-
|1995
|Iona
|Canisius
|-
|1996
|Iona
|Manhattan
|-
|1997
|Iona
|Canisius
|-
|1998
|Iona
|Marist
|-
|1999
|Iona
|Manhattan
|-
|2000
|Iona
|Marist
|-
|2001
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2002
|Iona
|Manhattan
|-
|2003
|Iona
|Loyola
|-
|2004
|Iona
|Marist
|-
|2005
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2006
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2007
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2008
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2009
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2010
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2011
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2012
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2013
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2014
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2015
|Iona
|Quinnipiac
|-
|2016
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2017
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2018
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2019
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2020
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2021
|Iona
|Iona
|-
|2022
|Iona
|Quinnipiac
|-
|2023
|Iona
|Quinnipiac
|-
|2024
|Iona
|Quinnipiac
|-
|2025
|Iona
|Quinnipiac
|}
Volleyball
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
Women's
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! width="40"|Year
! width="250"|Regular Season Champ
! width="100"|Tournament Champ
! width="200"|Most Outstanding/Valuable Player
|-
|1990
|La Salle
|Saint Peter's
|Dana Shepherd (La Salle) <br /> Jen Wutzer (La Salle)
|-
|1991
|La Salle
|Loyola
|Tara Vinje (Loyola)
|-
|1992
|Loyola
|Loyola
|Tara Vinje (Loyola)
|-
|1993
|Siena
|Siena
|Jeanine Bula (Siena)
|-
|1994
|Siena
|Siena
|Rochelle Travers (Siena)
|-
|1995
|
|Siena
|Rochelle Travers (Siena)
|-
|1996
|Fairfield
|Siena
|Donna DeFrancesco (Siena)
|-
|1997
|Fairfield
|Fairfield
|Jen McLaughlin (Fairfield)
|-
|1998
|Fairfield
|Fairfield
|Jen McLaughlin (Fairfield)
|-
|1999
|Fairfield
|Fairfield
|Corrine Carlson (Fairfield)
|-
|2000
|Fairfield
|Fairfield
|Joanne Saunders (Fairfield)
|-
|2001
|Saint Peter's
|Fairfield
|Laurie Brands (Fairfield)
|-
|2002
|Manhattan
|Manhattan
|Goedele Van Cauteren (Manhattan)
|-
|2003
|Manhattan
|Manhattan
|Goedele Van Cauteren (Manhattan)
|-
|2004
|Fairfield
|Iona
|Miki Hogg (Iona)
|-
|2005
|Fairfield
|Siena
|Christie Gustafson (Siena)
|-
|2006
|Fairfield (24–8 overall, 18-0 MAAC)
|Siena
|Christie Gustafson (Siena)
|-
|2007
|Siena (24–8 overall, 17-1 MAAC)
|Siena
|Nadiege Honore (Siena)
|-
|2008
|Fairfield (20–13 overall, 16-2 MAAC)
|Siena
|Burgandy McCurty (Siena)
|-
|2009
|Fairfield (19–12 overall, 16-2 MAAC)
|Niagara
|Hannah Hedrick (Niagara)
|-
|2010
|Niagara (25–9 overall, 17-1 MAAC)
|Niagara
|Hannah Hedrick (Niagara)
|-
|2011
|Niagara (25–9 overall, 17-1 MAAC)
|Niagara
|Kari Honomichl (Niagara)
|-
|2012
|Fairfield (22–9 overall, 15-3 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Brianna Dixion (Fairfield)
|-
|2013
|Marist (19–13 overall, 14-4 MAAC) <br /> Fairfield (21–9 overall, 14-4 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Rachel Romansky (Fairfield)
|-
|2014
|Marist (25–6 overall, 15-3 MAAC)
|Siena
|Rachel Stoklosa (Siena)
|-
|2015
|Fairfield (21–10 overall, 14-4 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Megan Theiller (Fairfield)
|-
|2016
|Fairfield (28–6 overall, 18-0 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Megan O'Sullivan (Fairfield)
|-
|2017
|Fairfield (25–7 overall, 18-0 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Skyler Day (Fairfield)
|-
|2018
|Iona (20–7 overall, 16-2 MAAC)
|Iona
|Mia Bonsignore (Iona)
|-
|2019
|Fairfield (24–6 overall, 17-1 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Manuela Nicolini (Fairfield)
|-
|2020^
|Fairfield (9-1 overall, 9-1 MAAC)
|Rider
|Anilee Sher (Rider)
|-
|2021
|Fairfield (24-9 overall, 16-2 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|K.J. Johnson (Fairfield)
|-
|2022
|Fairfield (26-7 overall, 17-1 MAAC)
|Quinnipac
|Aryanah Diaz (Quinnipac)
|-
|2023
|Fairfield (23-7 overall, 16-2 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Maya Walker (Fairfield)
|-
|2024
|Fairfield (21-11 overall, 17-1 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Mamie Krubally (Fairfield)
|-
|2025
|Fairfield (23-5 overall, 17-1 MAAC)
|Fairfield
|Kiannisha Santiago (Rider)
|}
^ Tournament delayed until April 2021 due to Covid
| valign="top" |
Postseason history
{|width="100%"
|-----
| valign="top" |
{| class=wikitable
<CAPTION ALIGN=TOP>NCAA tournament<br/>(1–32)</CAPTION>
|-
| Year
| MAAC Rep.
| Opponent
| Result
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1994
|Siena
|Princeton
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1995
|Siena
|Colgate <br /> Georgia Tech
|W 3–1 <br /> L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1996
|Siena
|Hofstra
|L 1–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1997
|Fairfield
|Ohio State
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1998
|Fairfield
|Clemson
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|1999
|Fairfield
|Michigan
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2000
|Fairfield
|Pepperdine
|L 1–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2001
|Fairfield
|Penn State
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2002
|Manhattan
|Temple
|L 1–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2003
|Manhattan
|Pepperdine
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2004
|Iona
|Nebraska
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2005
|Siena
|Washington
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2006
|Siena
|Minnesota
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2007
|Siena
|Penn State
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2008
|Siena
|California
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2009
|Niagara
|Michigan
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2010
|Niagara
|Penn State
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2011
|Niagara
|Northern Iowa
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2012
|Fairfield
|USC
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2013
|Fairfield
|Nebraska
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2014
|Siena
|Penn State
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2015
|Fairfield
|Texas
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2016
|Fairfield
|Michigan State
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2017
|Fairfield
|Texas
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2018
|Iona
|Pittsburgh
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2019
|Fairfield
|Minnesota
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2020
|Rider
|UCLA
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2021
|Fairfield
|UCLA
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2022
|Quinnipiac
|Wisconsin
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2023
|Fairfield
|Purdue
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2024
|Fairfield
|Wisconsin
|L 0–3
|- style="vertical-align: top;" |
|2025
|Fairfield
|Minnesota
|L 0–3
|}
|}
|}
Football
The MAAC Football League was formed before the 1993 season, but it was discontinued following the 2007 season.
At its peak in 1997, it consisted of 10 teams:
- Canisius (1993-2002, discontinued football after 2002 season)
- Duquesne (1994-2007, joined Northeast Conference after 2007 season)
- Fairfield (1996-2002, discontinued football after 2002 season)
- Georgetown (1993-1999, joined Patriot League after 1999 season)
- Iona (1993-2007, became independent, discontinued football after 2008 season)
- La Salle (1997-2007, discontinued football after 2007 season)
- Marist (1994-2007, became independent, joined Pioneer Football League after 2008 season)
- St. John's (1993-1997, became independent, joined Northeast Conference after 1999 season, discontinued football after 2002 season)
- Saint Peter's (1993-2006, discontinued football after 2006 season)
- Siena (1993-2003, discontinued football after 2003 season)
Champions
- 1993 Iona (5-0-0)
- 1994 Marist (6-1) & St. John's (6-1)
- 1995 Duquesne (7-0)
- 1996 Duquesne (8-0)
- 1997 Georgetown (7-0)
- 1998 Fairfield (6-1) & Georgetown (6-1)
- 1999 Duquesne (7-1)
- 2000 Duquesne (7-0)
- 2001 Duquesne (6-0)
- 2002 Duquesne (8-0)
- 2003 Duquesne (5-0)
- 2004 Duquesne (4-0)
- 2005 Duquesne (4-0)
- 2006 Duquesne (3-1) & Marist (3-1)
- 2007 Duquesne, Iona & Marist (all 2-1)
Ice hockey
History
The MAAC began sponsoring hockey in 1997 due to NCAA regulations that required all Division I conferences to participate in all Division sports. At the founding of the MAAC hockey conference, only three of the eight founding teams were full members of the conference: Canisius, Fairfield, and Iona. The MAAC also added five associate members: American International, Connecticut, Holy Cross, Quinnipiac, and Sacred Heart (at the time Quinnipiac and Sacred Heart were not members of the MAAC, though they would join the conference as full members later on). The conference began play starting with the 1998–99 season, where Quinnipiac and Holy Cross won the inaugural regular season and conference tournament championships, respectively. The MAAC added two additional teams starting with the 1999–00 season: Mercyhurst and Bentley. Army joined the conference for the 2000–01 season, bringing the conference up to eleven member teams. At the conclusion of the 2002–03 season, Fairfield and Iona both discontinued their men's ice hockey programs, and while the conference's remaining nine teams could continue without them, having only one full member necessitated the folding of the MAAC hockey conference as MAAC rules only allowed full conference members to vote in new decisions, leaving almost all MAAC hockey members without a voice in conference decisions pertinent to hockey. The following year all of the teams continued their programs in the newly formed Atlantic Hockey conference. As of the 2025–26 athletic season, five current MAAC members sponsor ice hockey, spread across the AHA, ECAC, and Hockey East conferences.
Ice hockey membership timeline
MAAC ice hockey membership often varied significantly from normal conference membership, with the majority of schools being associate members.
<timeline>
DateFormat = mm/dd/yyyy
ImageSize = width:800 height:auto barincrement:20
Period = from:01/01/1998 till:01/01/2004
TimeAxis = orientation:horizontal
PlotArea = right:30 left:0 bottom:50 top:5
Colors =
id:fm value:RGB(0.17647,0.7843,0.92157)
id:am value:rgb(0.961,0.62745,0.62745)
id:line value:black
id:bg value:white
PlotData=
width:15 textcolor:black shift:(5,-5) anchor:from fontsize:s
bar:AIC color:am from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:American International (1998–2003)
bar:CAN color:fm from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:Canisius (1998–2003)
bar:CON color:am from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:Connecticut (1998–2003)
bar:FAI color:fm from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:Fairfield (1998–2003)
bar:HC color:am from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:Holy Cross (1998–2003)
bar:ION color:fm from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:Iona (1998–2003)
bar:QIN color:am from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:Quinnipiac (1998–2003)
bar:SHU color:am from:06/01/1998 till:06/01/2003 text:Sacred Heart (1998–2003)
bar:BEN color:am from:06/01/1999 till:06/01/2003 text:Bentley (1999–2003)
bar:MER color:am from:06/01/1999 till:06/01/2003 text:Mercyhurst (1999–2003)
bar:ARM color:am from:06/01/2000 till:06/01/2003 text:Army (2000–2003)
ScaleMajor = gridcolor:line unit:year increment:2 start:01/01/1998
</timeline>
Champions
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center;"
! Season !! Regular Season Champion !! Tournament Champion
|-
! 1998-99
| Quinnipiac || Holy Cross
|-
! 1999-00
| Quinnipiac || Connecticut
|-
! 2000-01
| Mercyhurst || Mercyhurst
|-
! 2001-02
| Mercyhurst || Quinnipiac
|-
! 2002-03
| Mercyhurst || Mercyhurst
|}
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: center;"
! School !! Regular Season<br/>Championships !! Tournament<br/> Championships
|-
! Connecticut
| 0 || 1
|-
! Holy Cross
| 0 || 1
|-
! Mercyhurst
| 3 || 2
|-
! Quinnipiac
| 2 || 1
|}
Notable sports figures
Some of the notable sport figures who played collegiately and/or graduated from a MAAC school, include:
Baseball
<gallery perrow="5">
File:Luis Castro.jpg|Luis Castro <br /> 1st Hispanic in MLB <br /> Manhattan
File:AlDowning 10.jpg|Al Downing <br /> MLB All-Star Pitcher <br /> Rider
File:John Lannan.jpg|John Lannan <br /> MLB Pitcher <br /> Siena
File:Joe McCarthy.png|Joe McCarthy <br /> Hall of Fame MLB Manager <br /> Niagara
File:Jason Motte 2008.jpg|Jason Motte <br /> MLB Pitcher <br /> Iona
</gallery>
- Jack Armstrong, former MLB pitcher; 1990 MLB All-Star and World Champion (Rider)
- John Axford, former MLB pitcher (Canisius)
- Kevin Barry, former MLB pitcher (Rider)
- Shad Barry, former MLB player (Niagara)
- Chris Begg, pitcher for Team Canada at the 2004 Summer Olympics and World Baseball Classic (Niagara)
- Brad Brach, former relief pitcher (Monmouth)
- Frank Brooks, former MLB relief pitcher (Saint Peter's)
- Frank Cashen, former General Manager of the Baltimore Orioles and 1986 World Series Champion New York Mets (Loyola)
- Keefe Cato, former MLB pitcher (Fairfield)
- Tim Christman, former MLB relief pitcher (Siena)
- Harry Croft, former MLB player (Niagara)
- Pete Harnisch, MLB All-Star Pitcher (Fordham)
- Billy Harrell, former MLB infielder (Siena)
- Jim Hoey, former MLB relief pitcher (Rider)
- Gary Holle, former MLB first baseman (Siena)
- Miguel Jimenez, former MLB pitcher (Fordham)
- Jeff Kunkel, former MLB player; 3rd overall pick of the 1983 MLB Draft by the Texas Rangers (Rider)
- Sal Maglie, former starting pitcher (Niagara)
- Nick Margevicius, current starting pitcher for TSG Hawks (Rider)
- Joe McCarthy, former MLB catcher (Niagara)
- Rinty Monahan, former MLB player (Niagara)
- Ray Montgomery, former MLB player (Fordham)
- Danny Napoleon, former MLB outfielder (Rider)
- Mike Parisi, former MLB pitcher (Manhattan)
- Victor Santos, former MLB relief pitcher (Saint Peter's)
- Chuck Schilling, former MLB second baseman (Manhattan)
- Tom Waddell, former MLB pitcher (Manhattan)
Basketball
<gallery perrow="5">
File:HubieBrown1981.jpg|Hubie Brown, <br /> Hall of Fame NBA Coach <br /> Niagara
File:Calvin Murphy 1.jpg|Calvin Murphy, <br /> NBA All-Star Guard <br /> Niagara
File:Digger Phelps cropped.jpg|Digger Phelps, <br /> ESPN NCAA Analyst <br /> Rider
File:RikSmits.JPG|Rik Smits, <br /> NBA All-Star Center <br /> Marist
File:Mike Smrek in 2007.jpg|Mike Smrek <br /> Two-Time NBA Champion <br /> Canisius
</gallery>
- Joe Arlauckas, former NBA player (Niagara)
- John Beilein, former head coach of Cleveland Cavaliers and Michigan men's basketball (Canisius)
- Matt Brady, current Maryland assistant coach, former head coach of James Madison men's basketball (Siena)
- Steve Burtt, Sr., former NBA player (Iona)
- Al Butler, former NBA player (Niagara)
- Keydren Clark, two-time NCAA scoring leader; seventh all-time NCAA scoring leader (Saint Peter's)
- Larry Costello, former NBA player and coach; six-time NBA All-Star (Niagara)
- Joe DeSantis, former men's college basketball coach; 1979 NCAA All-American (Fairfield)
- Doug Edert, breakout star of Saint Peter's 2022 NCAA tournament run
- Kathy Fedorjaka, former Bucknell women's basketball coach (Fairfield)
- Luis Flores, former NBA player (Manhattan)
- Greg Francis, current Alberta men's basketball coach; former Canadian Olympic basketball player (Fairfield)
- Deng Gai, former NBA player; 2006 NCAA block shot leader (Fairfield)
- Sean Green, former NBA player (Iona)
- Kenny Hasbrouck, former NBA player (Siena)
- Bobby Joe Hatton – former professional basketball player; member of the Puerto Rico national basketball team at the 2004 Olympic Games (Marist)
- Stella Johnson, professional basketball player, drafted by Phoenix Mercury in 2020, played for Chicago Sky and Washington Mystics (Rider)
- Jared Jordan, professional basketball player in Europe, drafted by Los Angeles Clippers in 2007 (Marist)
- Frank Layden, former NBA coach and executive; NBA Coach of the Year and Executive of the Year (Niagara)
- Manny Leaks, former NBA player (Niagara)
- Tim Legler, former NBA player; current ESPN analyst (La Salle)
- Ralph Lewis, former NBA player (La Salle)
- Bob MacKinnon, former NBA Head Coach and General Manager of the New Jersey Nets (Canisius)
- Johnny McCarthy, member of the 1963–64 NBA Champion Boston Celtics and first of just three players in NBA history to record a triple-double in a playoff debut (Canisius)
- Brendan Malone, former NBA head coach (Iona)
- Michael Meeks, former Canadian Olympic basketball player (Canisius)
- Juan Mendez, professional basketball player in Europe; highest scoring Canadian in Division I men's basketball history (Niagara)
- Mike Morrison, former NBA player (Loyola)
- KC Ndefo, another key figure in Saint Peter's 2022 NCAA run
- Dan O'Sullivan, former NBA player (Fordham)
- Tim O'Toole, current ESPN analyst; former men's college basketball coach (Fairfield)
- Doug Overton, former NBA player (La Salle)
- Digger Phelps, current ESPN analyst; former men's college basketball coach (Rider)
- Darren Phillip, 2000 NCAA Top Rebounder (Fairfield)
- Rick Pych, current San Antonio Spurs executive (Fairfield)
- Jeff Ruland, former NBA player (Iona)
- Lionel Simmons, former NBA player (La Salle)
- Mike Smrek, former NBA player (Canisius)
- Jason Thompson, former Sacramento Kings lottery draft pick, former Toronto Raptors and Golden State Warriors forward (Rider)
- Edwin Ubiles former NBA player (Siena)
- Randy Woods, former NBA player (La Salle)
- A. J. Wynder, former NBA player (Fairfield)
Soccer
<gallery perrow="5">
File:Adam-braz-2008-10-05.jpg|Adam Braz, <br /> MLS Defender <br /> Fairfield
File:Milos Kocic TFC 2010.jpg|Miloš Kočić, <br /> MLS Goalie <br /> Loyola 2008
File:Justin-thompson-09-04-11.jpg|Justin Thompson, <br /> USL-1 Defender <br /> Fairfield
File:Zthorton.jpg|Zach Thornton, <br /> MLS All-Star Goalie <br /> Loyola 1998
</gallery>
- Jose Aguinaga, New York Red Bulls draft pick, former USL forward (Rider)
- Abby Allan, New Zealand women's national football team (Fairfield)
- Jamie Darvill, USL-2 player (Loyola)
- Anthony Di Biase, USL-2 player (Niagara)
- Bryan Harkin, USL-2 player (Fairfield)
- Christof Lindenmayer, former MLS player (Loyola)
- Mark Longwell, former U.S. National and NASL defender (Fairfield)
- Brett Maron, current player in Sweden, Goalkeeper (Fairfield)
- Jim McElderry, current Rutgers men's soccer coach and former Fordham men's soccer coach (Fairfield)
- Jim McKeown, former NASL defender (Rider)
- Tennant McVea, current USL League Two player and associate head coach for Old Dominion men's soccer, former Finnish Premier Division player (Loyola)
- Michael O'Keeffe, New Zealand men's national football team (Fairfield)
- Bobby Smith, National Soccer Hall of Fame member; former U.S. National and NASL defender (Rider)
- Matt Turner, Nottingham Forest and USMNT goalkeeper (Fairfield)
- Florian Valot, currently plays for Miami FC in USL, former player for New York Red Bulls and FC Cincinnati, midfielder/forward (Rider)
- Murphy Wiredu, former S. League player (Saint Peter's)
- Dennis Wit, former U.S. National and NASL player (Loyola)
- Jordan Scarlett, Tampa Bay Rowdies, drafted by New York Red Bulls, Defender (Iona)
- Ignacio Maganto, current player for Union Adarve in Tercera Division in Spain, drafted by Los Angeles Galaxy, Midfielder (Iona)