Peerage of England
|Earl of Surrey (1088)||William de Warenne, 5th Earl of Surrey||1199||1240||
|-
|Earl of Warwick (1088)||Henry de Beaumont, 5th Earl of Warwick||1203||1229||
|-
|rowspan=2|Earl of Devon (1141)||William de Redvers, 5th Earl of Devon||1193||1217||Died
|-
|Baldwin de Redvers, 6th Earl of Devon||1217||1245||
|-
|rowspan=2|Earl of Leicester (1107)||Simon de Montfort, 5th Earl of Leicester||1204°||1218||Died
|-
|Simon de Montfort, 6th Earl of Leicester||1218||1265||
|-
|Earl of Chester (1121)||Randolph de Blondeville, 4th Earl of Chester||1181||1232||
|-
|rowspan=2|Earl of Hertford (1135)||Richard de Clare, 4th Earl of Hertford||1173||1217||Died
|-
|Gilbert de Clare, 5th Earl of Hertford||1217||1230||
|-
|Earl of Arundel (1138)||William d'Aubigny, 3rd Earl of Arundel||1193||1221||
|-
|Earl of Derby (1138)||William de Ferrers, 4th Earl of Derby||1190||1247||
|-
|Earl of Norfolk (1140)||Roger Bigod, 2nd Earl of Norfolk||1177||1221||
|-
|rowspan=2|Earl of Oxford (1142)||Aubrey de Vere, 2nd Earl of Oxford||1194||1214||Died
|-
|Robert de Vere, 3rd Earl of Oxford||1214||1221||
|-
|Earl of Salisbury (1145)||William Longespée, 3rd Earl of Salisbury||1196||1226||
|-
|rowspan=2|Earl of Pembroke (1189)||William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke||1189||1219||Died
|-
|William Marshal, 2nd Earl of Pembroke||1219||1231||
|-
|rowspan=3|Earl of Essex (1199)||Geoffrey Fitz Peter, 1st Earl of Essex||1199||1213||Died
|-
|Geoffrey FitzGeoffrey de Mandeville, 2nd Earl of Essex||1213||1216||
|-
|William FitzGeoffrey de Mandeville, 3rd Earl of Essex||1216||1227||
|-
|Earl of Hereford (1199)||Henry de Bohun, 1st Earl of Hereford||1199||1220||
|-
|Earl of Winchester (1207)||Saer de Quincy, 1st Earl of Winchester||1207||1219||Died
Peerage of Scotland
|Earl of Mar (1114)||Gille Críst, Earl of Mar||Abt. 1178||Abt. 1220||
|-
|Earl of Dunbar (1115)||Patrick I, Earl of Dunbar||1182||1232||
|-
|rowspan=3|Earl of Angus (1115)||Gille Críst, Earl of Angus||1197||Abt. 1210||Died
|-
|Donnchadh, Earl of Angus||Abt. 1210||1214||Died
|-
|Máel Coluim, Earl of Angus||1214||1240||
|-
|rowspan=2|Earl of Atholl (1115)||Henry, Earl of Atholl||Abt 1190||1210||Died
|-
|Isabella, Countess of Atholl||1210||Abt. 1231||
|-
|Earl of Buchan (1115)||Margaret, Countess of Buchan||Abt. 1195||Abt. 1243||
|-
|Earl of Strathearn (1115)||Gille Brigte, Earl of Strathearn||1171||1223||
|-
|Earl of Fife (1129)||Máel Coluim I, Earl of Fife||1203||1228||
|-
|rowspan=2|Earl of Menteith (1160)||Muireadhach I, Earl of Menteith||Abt. 1190||Abt. 1213||Died
|-
|Muireadhach II, Earl of Menteith||Abt. 1213||Abt. 1230||
|-
|Earl of Lennox (1184)||Ailín I, Earl of Lennox||1184||1220||
|-
|Earl of Carrick (1184)||Donnchadh, Earl of Carrick||1186||1250||
|-
|Earl of Ross (1215)||Fearchar, Earl of Ross||1215||1251||New creation
|-
|}
Peerage of Ireland
|Earl of Ulster (1205)||Hugh de Lacy, 1st Earl of Ulster||1205||1242||
|-
|rowspan=2|Baron Athenry (1172)||Robert de Bermingham||1172||1218||Died
|-
|Peter de Bermingham||1218||1244||
|-
|}
Notes
- The transfer of the Earldom of Leicester was confirmed in 1207, although the fourth earl died in 1204. See Earl of Leicester.