AllMusic editor Jaime Sunao Ikeda rated the album three out of five stars. He noted that Paige "unleashes a voice with great development potential" on Jennifer Paige "that holds its own with a solid pop effort, and splendidly provides her own background vocals on most tracks as well. Definitely one of the brighter pop talents to emerge in quite a while. Standout tracks on this fine debut release include the first single "Crush," "Get to Me," "Somewhere, Someday," and the stellar "Let It Rain"."
Commercial performance
In the United States, Jennifer Paige debuted at number 168 on the US Billboard 200 on the week of August 29, 1998.
| style="text-align:center;"|3
|}