The Deschênes Commission, officially known as the Commission of Inquiry on War Criminals in Canada, was established by the government of Canada in February 1985 to investigate claims that Canada had become a haven for Nazi war criminals. Headed by retired Superior Court of Quebec judge Jules Deschênes, the commission delivered its report in April 1987, after almost two years of hearings.

Background

In December 1984, Sol Littman, the Canadian representative of the Simon Wiesenthal Center, wrote a letter to the Canadian government that he had obtained evidence that Josef Mengele had applied for a landed immigrant visa to Canada in 1962 under the name of Joseph Menke. Not receiving a response, Littman then had the story published in both the Toronto Star and The New York Times. The impact was immediate and the story was picked up by news outlets across the country.

On January 23, 1985, in the House of Commons of Canada, MP Robert Kaplan raised the issue of Mengele residing in Canada to the then Prime Minister Brian Mulroney. In response, Mulroney ordered the justice minister and Solicitor General to initiate an investigation into the validity of the accusations. On February 7, 1985, Justice Minister John Crosbie announced that Deschênes would head an independent Commission of Inquiry, with the task of investigating the charge that Nazi war criminals gained admittance to Canada by illegal or fraudulent means. The final report, dated December 30, 1986, was then tabled in the House of Commons on March 12, 1987. The Ukrainian and other communities were represented by the Civil Liberties Commission (CLC), which later became the Ukrainian Canadian Civil Liberties Association. The CLC was created in February 1985 by the Ukrainian Canadian Committee and several other eastern European and Baltic community organizations for the purpose of lobbying and interacting with the Deschênes Commission. It was chaired by Toronto lawyer John Gregorovich. The stated goals of the CLC were the following:

<blockquote>1. To take a public stand against the defamation against Ukrainians.

2. Represent the Ukrainian and eastern European communities at the Deschênes commission.

3. To show that membership in the Ukrainian Insurgent Army, Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists and the Ukrainian 1st division is not proof of participation in war crimes.

4. To prevent the use of Soviet evidence in the commission and Canadian courts.

5. Require that any Canadian accused of war crimes must be tried in a criminal court (stricter proof requirements).

6. To extend the scope of the Deschênes commission to include all criminals who performed crimes against humanity.</blockquote>

The Jewish community was represented by the Canadian Jewish Congress and B'nai Brith, with Sol Littman as spokesman.

Final report

The commission's final report was issued in April 1987 in two parts. The first part concluded that alleged Nazi war criminals had immigrated to Canada and in some cases were still residing in the country. The commission took selective approach to its mandate, investigating only allegations of Nazi war crimes (which were well-defined) and crimes against humanity (which at the time was a relatively new concept that concerned crimes that were not previously considered war crimes). Bernie Farber, then the director of the Canadian Jewish Congress, stated that Nazis in Canada, of which there were estimated to be 3,000, was the country's "dirty little secret". In the late 1990s, the issue of war criminals living in Canada and the Canadian government's lack of interest in searching for and prosecuting these individuals was the subject of investigative reporting by NBC, CBS, the CBC, Global Television, and The New York Times.

Olga Bertelsen published an article critical of the commission, claiming that the Soviets framed an innocent man, Ivan Demjanjuk, as part of a larger attempt (referred to as Operation Payback) by the KGB to sow discord between Canadian Jews and Ukrainians, a position that is shared by Lubomyr Luciuk, a professor at the Royal Military College of Canada who published the actual 1985 KGB document that proved this was indeed done. Luciuk was also critical of the commission's selective mandate, citing how the Commission itself had concluded that allegations about there being "thousands" of "Nazi war criminals" in Canada had been "grossly exaggerated". Those claims have been dismissed by the Simon Wiesenthal Center, and Holocaust history professors, such as Efraim Zuroff and Per Anders Rudling. Demjanjuk himself was not found guilty in Israel or the United States, and died behind bars in Germany, while his appeal was being heard.

While the commission's final report stated that the numbers were "grossly exaggerated," the report admitted that it had not investigated materials kept either in the Soviet Union or Eastern Bloc countries, and that it further had not investigated an addendum list of 109 names provided late in the inquiry. The commission's decision to find the 14th Waffen Grenadier Division of the SS (1st Galician) not guilty of collective war crimes was controversial in some circles.

On November 4, 2024 the Library and Archives Canada (LAC) told in a letter sent to all organisation, that have requested to publish full report according to Access to Information Act, that "decision has been made to withhold the Part II Report of the Deschênes Commission in its entirety". Scholars and Jewish organizations criticized, that they had not been invited to the consulting meetings. At the end of November 2024, historians Per Anders Rudling and Jared McBride called for the full publication of the Dêschenes Commission report and the release of all documents relating to war criminals, following the example of the United States.

See also

  • Ratlines (World War II)
  • Yaroslav Hunka scandal

References

  • Commission report
  • The report of the Commission of Inquiry on War Criminals is available online (in English and French).
  • B'nai B'rith Canada, "Traditional holding pattern on Nazi-era cases has made Canada a magnet for modern day war criminals, says B’nai Brith", August 18, 2006.
  • David Matas, "Seeking Global Justice", remarks to the federal Liberal caucus immigration roundtable, Regina, Saskatchewan, August 23, 2005.
  • Gloria Galloway, "Deportation calls mount against elderly Nazi 'enablers'", The Globe and Mail, January 30, 2007.
  • David Pugliese, "Whitewashing the SS: the Attempt to Re-Write the History of Hitler's Collaborators, Esprit-de-Corps, October 30, 2020.